Do all Muslims bear responsibility?

[BrianSoddingBoru4]

So, when a Christian loony shoots an abortion provider, all Christians bear the responsibility? More to the point, do you personally, as an atheist, feel that you bear the responsibility for Stalin's crimes?

Have you completely taken leave of your senses? A-theists. A lack of belief in god. Atheists have no shared doctrine, dogma or ideology. They don't share positive beliefs as a group.

Should we hold everyone who doesn't believe in Santa culpable for the actions of on a-Santa-ist?

Have a word with yourself

This is precisely the point: No, you DON'T hold everyone responsible for the actions of a few. But that is EXACTLY what was advocated in the OP.

Boru

---

Ermm, yeah OK. How much of this frivolous nonsense should I actually respond to?

I'd like to see you respond to all of it, but I don't hold out much hope. The out-of-hand dismissal of a counter to your loony idea of the en masse deportation of innocent people from the UK speaks volumes.

The first point I guess, as I doubt you are the type of person to concede even the slightest to any other opinion. Lets see;

On the contrary; I've conceded more points than you've had hot dinners. But (again) the fact that you opt not to respond tells me that you really don't have a cogent reply, so I'll ask again: How do you justify punishing 3 million people because of the actions of a tiny minority?

"Christian loony's shooting up abortion providers"
and, ok I don't even have to respond having read the rest of your first point.

But it isn't my point - it's yours. If a Muslim plants a bomb in a tube, or blows up a building, or shoots someone, then that Muslim should be punished. But YOU seem to want to punish ALL Muslims for the actions of a few. Fine, but you need to be consistent. If all Muslims share culpability for the actions of Muslim terrorists, why shouldn't all Christians share culpability for the actions of Christian ones?

"atheist, feel that you bear the responsibility for Stalin's crimes?"

Again, that is YOUR argument, not mine. Stalin was an absolute horror of a human being. He was also an atheist. For the rest of this point, see the para immediately preceding.

Holy disco biscuits............ have fun being you.

Easier than answering questions, innit?

Boru