A fined tuned argument.....Heywood style.

[Alex K]

If the universe were designed for life, we would precisely not be living on the edge in so many ways. You unwittingly killed your proposition A with the fine-tuning argument

I gotta digest the rest of your post and that will take me some time.

I do want to point out that I am talking about the universe being fine-tuned for emergent complexity....not life specifically.

I'm fine with that, I think my point remains valid then, except that one observation, the fact that large portions of space are uninhabitable and deadly, would not count as evidence against your proposition.