A fined tuned argument.....Heywood style.

[Heywood]

I haven't read through this thread yet (don't plan on reading through 9 pages of posts on a fundamentally useless argument), but have you brought up our inability to apply probabilities here Rasetsu?

Its a dilemma. A or B is going to be true. Without a way to distinguish probabilities the principle of indifference applies. The principle of indifference is what allows us to apply probability here.

Now some may claim, "There could be another possibility...something we don't yet know". This explanation is equivalent to "God works in mysterious ways". It isn't an explanation at all and deserves to be ignored.