A Serious Question For Theists

[John V]

Seriously?! "A little over the top?!"

Yes, seriously, a little over the top. Maybe not even that. If the same things were said by an atheist toward a theist, no one would have blinked.

Lets see how partisan we're going to be here. AM, you tell me if you think GC's comment above is in line with the scriptures I offered

I'm not going back to look, but it would be easy to find Scriptures with which such comments are not in line. But, they're not the only Scriptures. Consider Jesus' woes to the Pharisees, or Paul suggesting that his opponents cut their balls off.

and I'll tell you if I think esquilax is guilty of a logical fallacy (you'll have to find one).

You're confusing me for someone who cares about your opinion.