Do you have Questions about Islam ?

[robvalue]

You say only Allah decides who is a true Muslim.

If you wish to critically analyse your beliefs, I think this is a good place to start. This statement makes two massive assumptions.

First it assumes there is some sort of God, and in fact only one. There is no good evidence of this.

Secondly, it assumes that this God is more or less exactly the one described by Muslims, out of the infinity of possible gods. Again, no evidence for this, even after making the first assumption.

I imagine statements like the one you made come automatically, and that is a sure sign of bring programmed to think a certain way and to avoid looking deeper into what you're actually saying.

You seem to be on the path of challenging the Quran, making your own moral decisions, which is great. Once you remove that, what's left? A bunch of guys saying stuff with no evidence, that's been told to them by other guys with no evidence.


I hope that's of some help. Exactly the same applies to other God beliefs of course, scepticism picks equally on any God claim.