To the OP:
I find the whole thing very strange. I don't want to sound Cartesian, but I think of myself as a thinking thing, and I think of my gender as whatever my body is. So I cannot relate at all to feeling like one is the "wrong" gender. And likewise, I cannot relate to feeling like one is the "right" gender. I feel like a thinking thing, not like a particular gender. Not, that is, from introspection. When I look in the mirror, there is no doubt of what I am, but that does not at all explain why someone would feel like they should have a different body.
It reminds me of people who feel like they should be paraplegics or other things of a like nature. All of that is quite alien to me; I just feel like a thinking thing, and what my body is, is whatever it is. I don't feel like my body should be anything in particular.
So when I read Descartes, I know what he means, even though I don't agree with him on much.
Also, from speaking with others about this, I know I am not alone in how I feel about this from introspection.
I find the whole thing very strange. I don't want to sound Cartesian, but I think of myself as a thinking thing, and I think of my gender as whatever my body is. So I cannot relate at all to feeling like one is the "wrong" gender. And likewise, I cannot relate to feeling like one is the "right" gender. I feel like a thinking thing, not like a particular gender. Not, that is, from introspection. When I look in the mirror, there is no doubt of what I am, but that does not at all explain why someone would feel like they should have a different body.
It reminds me of people who feel like they should be paraplegics or other things of a like nature. All of that is quite alien to me; I just feel like a thinking thing, and what my body is, is whatever it is. I don't feel like my body should be anything in particular.
So when I read Descartes, I know what he means, even though I don't agree with him on much.
Also, from speaking with others about this, I know I am not alone in how I feel about this from introspection.
"A wise man ... proportions his belief to the evidence."
— David Hume, An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Section X, Part I.