Black People - Stop Blaming Racism, Take Responsibility

[Napoléon]

The first problem I would point out is that it proposes a kind of "libertarian" view that people are fully in control of their destiny and if they fail then they didn't work hard enough.

I don't think that's what he's saying. He's simply saying that all of the problems talked about in the video, aren't always down to other people. He's just saying that more responsibility should be taken by many people in the 'black community'. I don't disagree personally. But as a white, middle class man, I suppose some people will think I'm being racist or hate on me in some way for simply holding that perception.

Where's the research? Where's the evidence? What point are you exactly trying to make here?

It's just a guy, making a rant video. Not an academic thesis. Much of what he's saying doesn't even require evidence or research, it's already common knowledge, it's just one guy's opinion in the end anyway.

Besides the general gist of what he's saying doesn't even depend on whether some things are true or not. What claims did he make that you would require evidence for? Not asking to be a dick, but honestly, I can't fathom what you would actually be referring to. He wasn't making any unsubstantiated claims from what I could tell.

If you are looking for evidence on black people, or black communities being oppressed, or living in poverty, or their attitudes, I pointed in the direction of a few documentaries on the subject. It's not like the perceptions highlighted in the video are some brand new epiphany.

In terms of my point, I dunno, wasn't really making one per se. I agree with the guy in the video though, but if there are people who disagree then I'm eager to hear reasoning as to why not.

Saying "where's the evidence" doesn't really apply in this situation. Evidence for what?

Something like "Get out of the ghetto" is easier said than done. You see, when you grow up near people who deal drugs, spend your life seeing people dealing drugs, you will most likely end up dealing drugs as well. That's just nurturing. It's not as simple as "get out of the hole" otherwise there would be no poor people anywhere, don't you think?

I really get the feeling you've just completely missed anything relevant here and are just choosing to disagree with me.

Nobody made any claims about it being easy. In fact, in the video I posted with Ross Kemp, looking back on his time in Memphis, the guy he interviews says the precise OPPOSITE of that.

But it's not impossible. And it's not something people should just not attempt because they accept their lot in life. That's the entire point the guy was making. So you've been dealt a shitty hand. It's not about blaming other people, but doing what you can to make the best of it. Ofcourse not every case it's going to be possible. You really think I'm that naive? The reasons for poor people existing in the first place are more complex than just because they didn't try hard enough. I feel you're insulting my intelligence here.

The general point I think he's making in the vid, is that in the 'black community', or at least some/many in these communities don't do enough to 'get out of the ghetto'. Instead a lot of people like blaming others for their problems. He brought up slavery for precisely that point. Ain't no rich fuck going into the ghetto, graffitiing, littering and making it a run down mess with murders happening left right and centre. That's the people in the communities who do that.

And no, I don't really believe that running away from a cop legally allows murder regardless of the person's race.

I don't mean any disrespect here, but honestly, what kind of tinted glasses did you watch the video through that you thought anyone even came close to saying that?

It's also funny that he mentions slavery doesn't exist but there's lots of trafficking, maybe even more than 100 years ago (but that's a whole new topic).

Meh, I think you've really not got the point of anything he said.

Like I mentioned earlier, the reason he brought slavery up is that many people like to use that as an excuse for being in a poor neighbourhood, or having a shitty card dealt. Blame is still placed on the government, general attitudes are still bitter because of it. He's basically saying it shouldn't be this way. Chances are the average guy in the ghetto who's slinging dope on street corners with a gun under his belt doesn't know anyone who's been in slavery. But he's still content to break the law and then blame the system for him choosing the thug life.

Basic point is this: A lot of people in black communities like to blame others outside of the communities for their problems. Not many in the communities are actually doing enough to make the places they live a better place.

I know it's a lot to ask for you to watch, but Ross Kemp's documentary in Memphis basically comes to this conclusion.

Ofcourse, it's just one documentary, and one guy ranting into his camera. But I happen to agree. The flipside is someone will now more than likely claim I'm saying "black people have nothing to complain about" or "black people only have themselves to blame". That's not what I'm saying at all, but bring it on.