On Hell and Forgiveness

[GrandizerII]

It doesn't matter what he really feared. What matters for my point is that he experienced fear and other human weaknesses. I'm glad, by the way, that you've backtracked a little to concede that Jesus did experience fear according to the Bible.

But anyway, I'm well aware that you Christians have been conditioned to spiritualize almost everything that happened with Jesus, including this account of the Garden of Gethsemane. It's not like I've never attended sermons by Christian pastors elaborating on passages such as this, or done some Bible study sessions. So whatever, I'm all too happy to grant you that Jesus feared spiritual suffering, even if taken literally, the passage implies that he feared physical suffering.

But whatever it may be, he still experienced fear. That's all the point I'm trying to make here. Again, if your god is somehow able to experience human weakness via incarnation, then that's a problem for your argument that bravery cannot be considered a viable candidate for one of the great-making property for your god. Somehow, your god is able to be "beyond divine" by experiencing human weakness. How? No idea. But if he can experience fear, than bravery is something that can be applied to him as well.

Of course, theologians don't call the Christian God "brave", but we're not just doing theology here. If there's fear, then there's potential for bravery or courage or whatever you want to call it.

The real point to be made, though, is what others have argued earlier. That you're simply picking and choosing what goes into the set of great-making properties for the divine and what doesn't.

I have conceded nothing. I responded to your mocking of Jesus' "sorrow" mentioned in the passage as the reason for the distress. You cannot come up with a passage that says or even implies Jesus feared. You failed. Move on. I won't respond again.

So all these Christian theologians saying Jesus actually experienced fear were wrong, and you just happen to be right because ... why ... you overrate yourself? lol ...