RE: Is slack a private social club and other issues my sorry ass has landed itself in
April 20, 2019 at 7:32 am
(This post was last modified: April 20, 2019 at 7:56 am by robvalue.)
HThis is going to be my last post now before I take a break for a while, as this place isn’t for me right now. There’s many nice, reasonable people here and it’s a shame that my mental state is too fragile to cope with the people who aren’t so nice.
Here’s my personal opinion of how events unfolded here. People are welcome to disagree with my opinion.
1) Jorm made a topic in good faith, wishing to discuss a decision she didn’t understand on another platform.
2) She was not met with good faith back, received abuse from several people, and did not receive much in the way of meaningful discussion.
3) Fighting on, she managed to eventually discuss some of the points she wanted to talk about and got some answers. Those answers were pretty lame, in my opinion, but whatever. Run a private chat group however you like.
4) Jorm is being lectured about "breaking the prime directive", while doing no such thing in this thread as far as I can see, via posts that very much break that directive themselves. Huge hypocrisy. It was also way worse (in my opinion) than the breaking of some blasphemy-style law on the other group. She still carried on a lot longer than I’d have bothered to, to try and reach some meaningful agreement.
This is exactly the kind of non-discussion that is putting me off. It’s only a minority of people behaving this way, but this enough to make it toxic for me. This is a discussion forum, and discussion seems to be an afterthought.
People no doubt called me out for being a hypocrite when I complained about people being offensive to me in the other thread, after complaining about snowflake culture. I feel I should explain this point before I leave. Yes, in one respect I’m a snowflake myself because I am thin skinned at the moment. I’m mentally fragile. The difference is that I recognise that it’s me that doesn’t fit with the forum, not the other way around. I’m not requesting censorship, banning, or any other changes. I’m just voicing my opinions of why it’s not for me. The snowflake culture is to expect the environment to change around you, so that you no longer have to deal with people and opinions you don’t like. It’s also about deciding on other peoples' behalf what is offensive to them. (What is and isn’t offensive is highly subjective, I think. And being offensive isn’t a reason to be censored unless you’re actively harassing individuals.)
Now, much of what people "responded" to in that thread, I hadn’t actually said. They just imagined a load of other stuff that I probably thought, according to them, and replied to that. I wasn’t accusing anyone here of being a snowflake, nor talking about this forum, nor even specifically talking about the subject of blackface. I was making a general comment about my personal opinion about the direction society is headed. Since it was considered wrongthink by several people, the way to proceed is to have a non-discussion involving slinging mud until I either be quiet or change my opinion. Like I said, most of what was said didn’t even address what I said at all anyway. This kind of tactics is sadly the direction I see "debate" going in general. Whoever shouts the loudest wins. Again, this is a minority of people here, but enough to pierce my thin skin. And as such, I remove myself from the environment. For those that have been kind to me, I give my thanks and wish you well. Maybe I’ll return sometime in the future. I’ll continue to check my PMs.
PS: if anyone wants examples of what I was talking about regarding SJW and feminist ideology, then I invite you to take a listen. This stuff is everywhere. Again, I’m not talking about this forum, but society in general.
Here’s my personal opinion of how events unfolded here. People are welcome to disagree with my opinion.
1) Jorm made a topic in good faith, wishing to discuss a decision she didn’t understand on another platform.
2) She was not met with good faith back, received abuse from several people, and did not receive much in the way of meaningful discussion.
3) Fighting on, she managed to eventually discuss some of the points she wanted to talk about and got some answers. Those answers were pretty lame, in my opinion, but whatever. Run a private chat group however you like.
4) Jorm is being lectured about "breaking the prime directive", while doing no such thing in this thread as far as I can see, via posts that very much break that directive themselves. Huge hypocrisy. It was also way worse (in my opinion) than the breaking of some blasphemy-style law on the other group. She still carried on a lot longer than I’d have bothered to, to try and reach some meaningful agreement.
This is exactly the kind of non-discussion that is putting me off. It’s only a minority of people behaving this way, but this enough to make it toxic for me. This is a discussion forum, and discussion seems to be an afterthought.
People no doubt called me out for being a hypocrite when I complained about people being offensive to me in the other thread, after complaining about snowflake culture. I feel I should explain this point before I leave. Yes, in one respect I’m a snowflake myself because I am thin skinned at the moment. I’m mentally fragile. The difference is that I recognise that it’s me that doesn’t fit with the forum, not the other way around. I’m not requesting censorship, banning, or any other changes. I’m just voicing my opinions of why it’s not for me. The snowflake culture is to expect the environment to change around you, so that you no longer have to deal with people and opinions you don’t like. It’s also about deciding on other peoples' behalf what is offensive to them. (What is and isn’t offensive is highly subjective, I think. And being offensive isn’t a reason to be censored unless you’re actively harassing individuals.)
Now, much of what people "responded" to in that thread, I hadn’t actually said. They just imagined a load of other stuff that I probably thought, according to them, and replied to that. I wasn’t accusing anyone here of being a snowflake, nor talking about this forum, nor even specifically talking about the subject of blackface. I was making a general comment about my personal opinion about the direction society is headed. Since it was considered wrongthink by several people, the way to proceed is to have a non-discussion involving slinging mud until I either be quiet or change my opinion. Like I said, most of what was said didn’t even address what I said at all anyway. This kind of tactics is sadly the direction I see "debate" going in general. Whoever shouts the loudest wins. Again, this is a minority of people here, but enough to pierce my thin skin. And as such, I remove myself from the environment. For those that have been kind to me, I give my thanks and wish you well. Maybe I’ll return sometime in the future. I’ll continue to check my PMs.
PS: if anyone wants examples of what I was talking about regarding SJW and feminist ideology, then I invite you to take a listen. This stuff is everywhere. Again, I’m not talking about this forum, but society in general.
Feel free to send me a private message.
Please visit my website here! It's got lots of information about atheism/theism and support for new atheists.
Index of useful threads and discussions
Index of my best videos
Quickstart guide to the forum
Please visit my website here! It's got lots of information about atheism/theism and support for new atheists.
Index of useful threads and discussions
Index of my best videos
Quickstart guide to the forum