Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: August 29, 2024, 12:43 am

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
How it was forged.
#41
RE: How it was forged.
MysticKnight


Although this is not the topic of what you have posted -since it discusses how sunnies & shia alike forged Islam-, it's about forgery not what to follow. 

In many movies and video games, there are things that don't contradict the Quran or negate it, I follow it with no problems, like the lovely sentence which is so accurate : "fear of the blood brings fear of the flesh". But I never come and trace it back to Mohammed peace be upon him, or to God.

Though out of topic, follow whatever you wanna follow; but never say "God said it" or "Mohammed said it" or even "Ali said it" when it's a Hadith. And a source.

As a matter of direct order from God :

( Sura 39 Verse 55 )   And follow the best of what was revealed to you from your Lord before the punishment comes upon you suddenly while you do not perceive,

and of course, the best that was revealed is (Quoting God again) :

( Sura 39 Verse 23 )   Allah has sent down the best statement: a consistent Book wherein is reiteration. The skins shiver therefrom of those who fear their Lord; then their skins and their hearts relax at the remembrance of Allah. That is the guidance of Allah by which He guides whom He wills. And one whom Allah leaves astray - for him there is no guide.
Reply
#42
RE: How it was forged.
The only way to validate the Sunnah and why we should follow the Sunnah of Mohammad and the family of Mohammad is through Quran. So Quran is the greater of the weighty trusts, but we still need to follow the leaders it appoints and not turn away from their authority.

Quran command us to obey the Messenger and those who possess the authority from us.
Reply
#43
RE: How it was forged.
(October 3, 2015 at 11:29 am)MysticKnight Wrote: The only way to validate the Sunnah and why we should follow the Sunnah of Mohammad and the family of Mohammad is through Quran. So Quran is the greater of the weighty trusts, but we still need to follow the leaders it appoints and not turn away from their authority.

Quran command us to obey the Messenger and those who possess the authority from us.

You have a brain.  Use it.  Why do you need other people to tell you what to think?  You might as well be a camel.  You are supposed to be an intelligent human being living in the 21st Century.  Stop acting like you're in the 21st Century BC.
Reply
#44
RE: How it was forged.
Some people are brought up being told how and what to think and don't know any different. I have some sympathy for Theists. It can be extremely hard for Theists to think any differently. Fear of hellfire is one thing. Even something that looks so simple like taking off head coverings in public can be hard for them.

Reply
#45
RE: How it was forged.
I knew about the clock tower already, actually and that the Abraj Al Bait was built by the Saudi Binladin Group (lol). Though it does seem symbolic that they would put the calligraphy for the word “Allah” above any Saudi symbols. But then they ruin it by putting that Pagan moon symbol above Allah. The crescent moon has a variety of meanings, such as being associated with Lord Shiva from Hinduism or Tenguri (crescent and pole represents this deity).

The story goes that a certain Ottoman sultan had a dream and decided to adopt the symbol. Not sure why he would want to adopt such a symbol, but my guess is he got his inspiration it from Tengurism, the ancient religion of the Turkic people. But what I find fascinating is the use of the symbol on Mosques built before the Ottomans conquered the area, such as atop the Great Mosque of Damascus, where the shrine to John the Baptist is (the pope, John Paul 2, visited this Mosque for this reason). The Umayyad Mosque has some fine architecture and DEASH has a habit of following the example of Abdul Wahaab so I hope the Syrians can at least keep it safe.

If I had one, would beat the Saudi flag with my shoe. Then again, it has the Shahada on it, so maybe the coat of arms of Saudi is better so I offend less people. Saudi is the reason why I can't seem to have an intelligent discussion with Sunnis. Their minds have become corrupted by the Saudi narrative. Immediately they jump to science in the Quran. Or maybe I've just had rotten luck.

Shia have people like Yasser Al-Habib (born in Kuwait apparently), sure, but he doesn't have the reach of someone like Zakir Naik or Yusuf Estes, both of whom are considered mainstream in Sunni circles. And, sure, Press TV is Iranian propaganda, but this nothing compared with what Saudi does. Why the United Kingdom would grant someone like Yasser Al-Habib asylum is confusing considering they ban Zakir Naik from entering the country. That seems like a double standard.

It didn't even used to be the case that Kathir couldn't enter Mecca, apparently. The Sikh Guru, Nanak, went to Mecca during his travels. People use this fact against Sikhs but there is nothing to suggest he completed any pilgrimage. He merely passed through Mecca. I know Quran 9:28 says idolaters are not approach the Sacred Mosque, but I see a number of problems with the Iyah.

Quran 9:28 “O ye who believe! Truly the Pagans are unclean; so let them not, after this year of theirs, approach the Sacred Mosque. And if ye fear poverty, soon will Allah enrich you, if He wills, out of His bounty, for Allah is All-knowing, All-wise.”

First, like many Iyah in the Quran, it doesn't mention Mecca by name. People simply assume that it's referring to Mecca. I remember there is a man named Dan Gibson who visited many early Mosque sites and found the Qublia was not always facing Mecca.
This is his website I believe:
http://www.searchformecca.com/
(There are various resources available for download, and a book to buy, for those interested)

Second, the verse is more interesting for what it doesn't say rather what it does. Atheist, by definition, can't be Pagans so should they be allowed near the Sacred Mosque? Saudi loves money so they could turn Mecca into a world famous tourist attraction, like the Vatican is, if they haven't already. It would certainly help with the Dawah. I wouldn't be surprised if the Saudis were artificially keeping the Zamzam spring flowing.

Contaminated 'Zam Zam' holy water from Mecca sold in UK, BBC article

The article says “"Zam Zam" water is gathered from a well in Mecca but there is a ban on exporting it from Saudi Arabia”, which could be interpreted as giving credence to the theory that Saudi is artificially adding water to the spring. I say this because it may be the case the Saudi doesn't want the water to be tested and people find out that it's just plain tap water and the spring dried out years ago.

Thirdly this verse has to be one of the reasons Saudi gives for barring Kathir from Mecca. However, it provides no definition of what a Pagan actually is. Some would even consider Christians Pagan and cite various reasons for doing so. This is once again the Saudi establishment forcing their interpretation upon others and it reinforces the need for Mecca to be independent of the al-Saud family and the Wahaabi (i.e. Salafist) narrative they promote.

I also knew about the Doomsday Clock. Fortunately there was that Fawta (not exactly a Fawta, but whatever) against climate change, so there is some hope. The United States is full of hypocrites who would like to deny that the United States likes to bully everyone.

Just yesterday we learnt of the Afghan hospital bombing yet at the same time the United States is accusing the Russian Federation of killing civilians in Syria. And we also had Texas senator Ted Cruz making death threats against the Ayatollah recently too. And then they wonder why people chant “death to America”. There are so many reasons to hate the United States – the list is seemingly endless. But at least we can NASA for memory foam mattresses, pocket calculators and amazing photographs of all of the planets, including Pluto.

While we're on the subject of NASA, I must correct you on something. We don't need the sun or moon for plants to grow. Plants, including edible ones, have been grown on the International Space Station without the use of sunlight and then eaten. They use artificial lights that replicate the effect of sunlight.

I sort of understand what you're referring to when you talk about your religious slavery. But it's paradoxical. You can never be completely free from Earthly desires. I see all these (Sunni) Fascist Da'is preaching about how we shouldn't be materialistic yet they sponge off of those that donate to them and wear designer clothes and go on so many nice holidays whilst those they take advantage of suffer. I know that DawahMan, for example, has been reported for fraud by TheRatioanlizer.

I don't remember you telling me personally that you're not a Sunni, but now I know. Regardless, I think we have talked about slavery enough. I'm not suggesting you like to wear peculiar hats but where I live is nothing like the United States, where big business does dominate to an unhealthy degree. If people care about Capitalism then they would put measures in place to restrain big business from becoming too powerful. Funny how Americans lecture the rest of the world about Democracy when there is none where they live.

I was not suggesting Allah has human attributes, even though Allah is shown to get angry and is vengeful against the Jews. I'm surprised Iran and Africans have been blamed for the recent troubles in Mecca and it's not been the fault of Zionists for once. However, what I am saying is that it was non-nonsensical for Iblis to refuse to bow before Adam. Allah created Iblis knowing this would happen. I could create a better universe than Allah if I was given the same powers Allah is said to have.

Reply
#46
RE: How it was forged.
(October 3, 2015 at 3:27 pm)Wyrd of Gawd Wrote: You have a brain.  Use it.  Why do you need other people to tell you what to think?  You might as well be a camel.  You are supposed to be an intelligent human being living in the 21st Century.  Stop acting like you're in the 21st Century BC.

The way Quran is written, it's not force full into what to think. It rather helps you ponder if you let it help you, and it opens doors to reflection over topics, while being a silent speaker in many ways.
Reply
#47
RE: How it was forged.
 ?MysticKnight


There's a context for that verse -as of course for any other verse in the book-; allow me quote the verse first :

(Sura 4 Verse 59 )   O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allah and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in result.

First, it didn't deny the fact that we might disagree on matter between us --between us & the leaders--. In other words; it's okay to raise your hand & object.
Second, it told us in the case of disagreeing, to take the matter to God or his Messenger. But what if the messenger is dead ?
Third, then we return it to God. And that's it , each stands & brings his/her evidence from what God said -i.e Quran-.

It didn't call us to obey nobody but God after all.

If the majority voted for an opinion, then that goes. If somebody doesn't like the result, he/she should leave the scene.

But God didn't give nobody a leader status but the Messenger .. Nobody else.

MrNoMorePropaganda


Quote:Some people are brought up being told how and what to think and don't know any different. I have some sympathy for Theists. It can be extremely hard for Theists to think any differently. Fear of hellfire is one thing. Even something that looks so simple like taking off head coverings in public can be hard for them.

I always believed that for many of them, it's fear of society before anything else.
Come to the Middle East. You'll be speechless when you see a Wahhabi teaching about Sunni Islam in the day, yet sexually harassing young boys in the night.

I will reply to your comment.
Reply
#48
RE: How it was forged.
AtlasS33, because you reject all Hadith does this mean you don't follow any Madhhab? Jafari? Ismali? Zadi? Or something else?

Reply
#49
RE: How it was forged.
Atlas, I am very aware of the context. I'm also aware of mistranslated translations of the word "fa". For example, you put it as "and" while it really means "so/therefore".

But let's give an example, if the Prophet said:


Verily Allah appointed the family of Ibrahim as leaders, and who turned away from their guidance was in hell, and those who followed them benefited from their leadership. O you who believe Obey God and obey me and the Leaders from you. Verily people you are required to obey me to the extent you refer all disputes back to my judgement. And indeed people were always required to obey the Prophets by God's permission and all Prophets were sent to be obeyed. Indeed who obeys me has indeed obeyed God.


You talk about context, but anyone in their right mind would say here leaders in any type leader or that the obedience here is not absolute and doesn't include spiritual authority?

Now let's look at the context, as you in own words, the context is important:

"Have you not seen a portion of those who were given a portion of the book, they believe in the Jibt (sorcery) and Taghut (inordinate false authority) and say these are more guided then those who believe. Or do they have a share in the authority then they would not give the people at date stone. Or do they envy the people for what God has given them out his grace, so then indeed we gave the family of Ibrahim the book, the wisdom, and gave them a great authority. So of them is who believed in it and of them of is who turned away from it, and sufficient is hell as a burning. Indeed those who disbelieve in God's Ayat (Signs/revelations/guidance), soon we will enter them the fire, so as often their skins are thoroughly burned, we will change them for other skins, that they taste the chastisement, surely God is Mighty, Wise.  As for those who believe and do good deeds, we will make them enter gardens beneath which rivers flow, to abide in them for ever, they shall have therein pure mater, and we shall make them enter a dense shade. Verily Allah commands you to make over the trusts to to their owners and that when they judge between people you judge with justice, surely Allah admonishes you with what is excellent surely Allah is seeing, Hearing. O You who believe, obey God and obey the Messenger and those who possess the Command/Authority from you, therefore if you dispute with regards to a thing, refer it to God and the Messenger if you believe in God and the last day, that is better and most suitable at the end. Have you not seen those who assert that they believe in what has been revealed to you and what was revealed before you? They desire to summon one another to the judgment of the Taghut, though they were commanded to deny it, and the Shaitan desires to lead them astray into a remote error. And when it is said to them: Come to what God has revealed and to the Messenger, you will see the hypocrites turning away from you with (utter) aversion. But how will it be when misfortune befalls them on account of what their hands have sent before? Then they will come to you swearing by God: We did not desire (anything) but good and concord. These are they of whom God knows what is in their hearts; therefore turn aside from them and admonish them, and speak to them effectual words concerning themselves. And We did not send any messenger but that he should be obeyed by God's permission; and had they, when they were unjust to themselves, come to you and asked forgiveness of God and the Messenger had (also) asked forgiveness for them, they would have found God Oft-returning (to mercy), Merciful.


Now God is going to judge between us who is twisting the verse out of it's place.

Let's give an example of how translating the word "fa" into therefore/so changes the meaning.


Eat fruits and vegetables they are good for you therefore eat your orange and carrot. 

 

Does not mean not to eat other fruits and vegetables. But say given you have an orange and carrot with you or they are available, it's telling you eat them.

 

Likewise

 

Listen to your teachers in school therefore do the homework Mr. Fleming assigns you. 

 
Doesn't mean you don't do the homework other teachers assign. Perhaps Mr. Fleming is your main teacher at that time, doesn't mean the next year, you don't listen to your teacher.


Reply
#50
RE: How it was forged.
It's interested that the word "forged" is used in the thread title...

Playing Cluedo with my mum while I was at Uni:

"You did WHAT?  With WHO?  WHERE???"
Reply





Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)