Atheism and vegetarianism

[Edwardo Piet]

[...]organisms tend to do what they naturally do as long as they have the power to do it.

Well yeah! That's a tautology. Of course things tend to do what they naturally do, and of course they can only do it if they have the power to do it

[fr0d0]

Morality is the system where ethics are the components. It's simpler to talk about ethics. Is it ethically justifiable to cause unnecessary suffering as we can know creatures to experience? It's a single consideration and not a whole moral system to cloud the issue.

I don't think it is justifiable.

[Edwardo Piet]

I agree but it depends on alternatives IMO. I'm entirely consequentialist.

Morality is what is moral. Ethics is the study of what is moral, the study of morality. Ethics is morality discussed, right?

[Minimalist]

“I am not a vegetarian because I love animals; I am a vegetarian because I hate plants.”

A. Whitney Brown quote

Now, I have to run out and grill some dead cow to enjoy with my red wine.

[fr0d0]

5 morals and 2 ethics

Killing to eat is justifiable. Causing unnecessary suffering is ethically undesirable. You want to justify that on monetary or convenience grounds?

[Edwardo Piet]

No, see my earlier post, post #5 here.

[Minimalist]

Morality is what is moral. Ethics is the study of what is moral, the study of morality. Ethics is morality discussed, right?

Let me know when you get back to food. I love a good steak. I do not deny the right or desire of the vegetarians to eat grass or moss if they like. Not for me, though.

[cdog]

So you eat rice and broccoli? That stuff that just gets in the way of the meat? Insanity! I don't understand why a person wouldn't eat pigs , cows, deer etc., but would eat fish. I can't see the difference between killing a cow for the purpose of consuming it flesh, and killing a fish, crab or whatever for the same purpose.

[lrh9]

[...]organisms tend to do what they naturally do as long as they have the power to do it.

Well yeah! That's a tautology. Of course things tend to do what they naturally do, and of course they can only do it if they have the power to do it

Then morality is an unnecessary variable.

[darkwolf176]

Eating fish is NO different to eating meat!!! Fish is meat!

I never said it wasn't, I don't like other types of meat.