Tooth Fairy Bullshit

[Catholic_Lady]

Doesn't make me insecure at all. I feel very secure in my beliefs. Which is why I have 0 need to go around and make fun of everyone else's, or of those who have none.  

But if you asked me if I found it insulting for you to equate the beliefs I hold, to those held by 4 year olds and adults that are legitimately nuts... then yeah, I'd tell you I do. Seems pretty logical that I would. If you want to continue to accuse me of being insecure for this reason despite me telling you otherwise, go ahead I guess. Seems to give ya'll some sense of superiority, so knock yourselves out.

Oh no, not superiority, just telling you and others that believe in gods, what I think of it. You take it offensive? That is too bad, but if the way I think makes you shake, then it is insecurity. I am going to tell you how I think, not sugar coat it, make it all polite and dandy. I respect that you are free to believe. You should try also to accept critique of your beliefs.

I am perfectly fine with critique of my beliefs. But as I have explained... there's a difference between critiquing a person's belief, and equating that person's belief to a belief that only children hold. When you say the beliefs I hold are equal to those help by children, you're essentially calling me childish/crazy/stupid. So yeah, that's insulting.    

It's like one of your friends telling you you're a childish idiot and then asking if it insults you. You say "yes" and then they accuse you of being insecure.

[Neo-Scholastic]

Yeah, keep on throwing out insults, NS. That makes us want to take you seriously, asshat. I was going to break that down, but I don't like you. I'm not trying to insult CL, but I would be more than happy to insult you all day.

You can dish it out, but you can't take it. That's why you keep backing away into the insincere bullshit that you "can disrespect a belief without disrespecting the believer." That may be true in general, but not with respect to this issue.

[LastPoet]

Perhaps it would help it I gave an example of what would be a fair comparison to God, namely Truth. Consider the following two propositions:

P1: The tooth fairy exists.
P2: Truth exists.

In one trivial respect some smartasses could claim that neither of the proposition’s subject has sufficient empirical evidence to justify belief in it. I challenge these Champions of Reason to justify their self-conceit of being Truthseekers without tangible falsifiable evidence that Truth exists.
If there was a tooth fairy, someone could at least, in theory, set a pair of dentures on a mousetrap and catch one. Not so with truth. If truth exists then it isn’t just another thing in a universe full of things. Has anyone seen truth? Distilled it into a test-tube? It’s not even reasonable to suggest that belief in truth is justified only after a sample has been produced under controlled conditions. Truth cannot be isolated. Either it informs everything or it doesn’t. Any comparison between the existence of the tooth fairy and truth is a ludicrous and obvious category error. I question the intellectual integrity of those who deny it.

I take that back. I don’t question it. They dishonest. Why is it that skeptics compare the existence of God to fairies, unicorns, and other fantastic mythological beasts as opposed to the existence of things like truth or personal identity or Platonic Forms or moral principles? I will tell you why. Because their only intention is to make believers seem ridiculous. Douches.

So close, yet too far. You know this chad, you really have to believe in the tooth fairy, e.g. have faith. the tooth fairy will be obvious to all that already believe, setting all your premises true by default.

And you are the one being dishonest claiming absolute knowlege, yet, not evident to all humans. Go hide your ass in a monastery or something. mabe your god will come to you there.

[AceBoogie]

Catholic_Lady is my favorite, even if she does think I'm a heathen.






Neo.... not so much

[Jesster]

Yeah, keep on throwing out insults, NS. That makes us want to take you seriously, asshat. I was going to break that down, but I don't like you. I'm not trying to insult CL, but I would be more than happy to insult you all day.

You can dish it out, but you can't take it.

I said 50,000 times that my comparison of your beliefs to the tooth fairy was not meant as an insult. You took it as an insult, but that's not my problem. If you want to throw a fit about it by tossing your personal offense at others, then I'm just going to shake my head at your butthurt and laugh. Fuck off.

[LastPoet]

I am perfectly fine with critique of my beliefs. But as I have explained... there's a difference between critiquing a person's belief, and equating that person's belief to a belief that only children hold. When you say the beliefs I hold are equal to those help by children, you're essentially calling me childish/crazy/stupid. So yeah, that's insulting.    

It's like one of your friends telling you you're a childish idiot and then asking if it insults you. You say "yes" and then they accuse you of being insecure.

It is perfectly your right to feel insulted. I tell the same thing to my mom and sisters. Good thing I am pro at Krav Maga Evasion. But that is just how it is. I find belief in any maistream religion infantile. Well, no one is perfect. You have good qualities too. A gentle caring personality and other stuff that Mr_CL can enumerate surely. I am sorry, but I won't be sorry for the way I think <---- See what I did there?

*runs off*

[Neo-Scholastic]

I said 50,000 times that my comparison of your beliefs to the tooth fairy was not meant as an insult. You took it as an insult, but that's not my problem.

It doesn't matter what you intended. What matters it that is is an insult. Both CL and I have explained to you why it is insulting and yet you persist. It's like accidentally saying to an African-Amercian that you are surprised at how well-spoken they are, being informed that it is condescending, but then continuing to say it anyway...because you don't mean it that way. It is your problem.

[Catholic_Lady]

Honestly, I'm not even complaining. You guys can equate my belief to belief in tooth fairies all day long. I've seen tons of threads and posts about it. I don't try to stop you or silence you. In fact, I never say a word about it.

However, I figured for once I'd come in here and confirm that yes, I think someone equating the beliefs I hold to those held by children is insulting to my character, to my intelligence, to my maturity, and to my mental state. And I figured I'd explain *why* I find it insulting.

That's it. I'm not trying to stop anyone from continuing to say those things. Just explaining my views on it and how I feel about it. Now so long as everyone correctly understands what my views are, as I have tried to explain many times now on this thread, I don't have anything further to say, and nothing to complain about.

Oh, and calling me insecure was insulting as well, but what can you do.

[LastPoet]

It doesn't matter what you intended. What matters it that it is an insult. Both CL and I have explained to you why it is insulting any yet you persist. It's like accidentally saying to an African-Amercian that you are surprised at how well-spoken they are, being informed that it is condescending, but then continuing to say it anyway...because you don't mean it that way.

Telling one's beliefs is racist now?

Where is the spanish inquisition when we need one?

[Jesster]

It doesn't matter what you intended. What matters it that it is an insult. Both CL and I have explained to you why it is insulting any yet you persist. It's like accidentally saying to an African-Amercian that you are surprised at how well-spoken they are, being informed that it is condescending, but then continuing to say it anyway...because you don't mean it that way.

Yeah, I'm not going to dance around your trigger warnings anymore. Have fun with your fit. I'm not going to let your issues bother me.