[Quranic Reflection]: Quran vs Hadith- why the Hadith is false

[Ranjr]

We did have our progress and even built the stronger empire of the medieval world. Its capital was Baghdad, and believe it or not, everything modern people do today was spread there; even drinking coffee regularly and having huge universities.

Our golden age met its end at the hands of the Mongols:

That's great and something to be proud of.  So, a millennium later?  No rebound?  Still vulnerable to outside invaders?  Yeah. That's what I've been saying.  How's it working out for you?

[Deesse23]

....and your almighty god wasnt able to change it, for the past 1500 years?
What a shitty track record.

We did have our progress ....

Your "answer" does not adress my post, at all. Try again.

The Rashidun caliphate was the first muslim empire. It had only four rulers until it was overthrown after a civil war and lasted a mere 30 years. Its third ruler was already assassinated. This tradition continued. The second caliphate didnt last much longer, 100 years. After that you see more internal division, strife, sedition and unrest.
Your god has a shitty track record of keeping people on the arab peninsula from killing each other.

There is no "we".
Islam, like Christianity, while spreading violently as a whole, was, is and will always be plagued by internal subdivision. If you need evidence, just have a look in the mirror. From a historic perspective, you are no more than just a further contribution to Islams subdivision and downfall.

[Pat Mustard]

Islam not only didn't change the barbarity, it prevents progress toward better lives for all people in the Middle East.  It keeps them entrenched in the violent past.

We did have our progress and even built the strongest, most prosperous  empire of the medieval world. Its capital was Baghdad, and believe it or not, everything modern people do today was spread there; even drinking coffee regularly and having huge universities.

Our golden age met its end at the hands of the Mongols:

It's not anybody else's fault that islamic rulers were stupid enough to butcher Chinggis' trade envoys. Oh and the Mongols didn't become enamoured with killing for killing's sake until, guess what, they became muslims.

[Deesse23]

We did have our progress and even built the strongest, most prosperous empire of the medieval world. Its capital was Baghdad

Which one? The Abbasid caliphate? It lasted 100 years, before it fractured due to internal subdivision for another 100 years. Your gods track record of keeping muslims from fighting each other still is miserable.
It then was controlled for 200 years by foreign powers (Bujids and Seljuqs). Strong? Not so much, i guess. For another 100 years it gained back control, only to be crushed by the Mongols. Strong? I doubt so.

, and believe it or not, everything modern people do today was spread there; even drinking coffee regularly and having huge universities.

And the achievements of the islamic golden age are thanks to to chopping hands off, discriminating against women or torturing and crucifying looters and pillagers how?

Our golden age met its end at the hands of the Mongols:

Nope, your obsession with power and violence has blinded you once again. Great cultures dont have to rule great parts of the globe, one of your many and fundamental misconceptions.

[WinterHold]

We did have our progress and even built the stronger empire of the medieval world. Its capital was Baghdad, and believe it or not, everything modern people do today was spread there; even drinking coffee regularly and having huge universities.

Our golden age met its end at the hands of the Mongols:

That's great and something to be proud of.  So, a millennium later?  No rebound?  Still vulnerable to outside invaders?  Yeah. That's what I've been saying.  How's it working out for you?

When empires collapse, they usually become "vassals" of the successful powers around; the Muslims became vassals of the west in our time; especially the Arab countries, each western superpower has its vassals around the Middle East; and when one of the vassals "revolt" or "change loyalty" they get butchered, like Iraq during Saddam's reign.

---

We did have our progress and even built the strongest, most prosperous  empire of the medieval world. Its capital was Baghdad, and believe it or not, everything modern people do today was spread there; even drinking coffee regularly and having huge universities.

Our golden age met its end at the hands of the Mongols:

It's not anybody else's fault that islamic rulers were stupid enough to butcher Chinggis' trade envoys.  Oh and the Mongols didn't become enamoured with killing for killing's sake until, guess what, they became muslims.

I wouldn't say "Muslim(s)" but a single "Muslim" ruler did that, I would understand though if Mongols butchered eastern Muslims only, but they didn't stop there and kept butchering the whole world.

Genghis Khan was a savage butcher all along. His dynasty even boiled Koreans alive !

[The Architect Of Fate]

I wouldn't say "Muslim(s)" but a single "Muslim" ruler did that, I would understand though if Mongols butchered eastern Muslims only, but they didn't stop there and kept butchering the whole world.

Genghis Khan was a savage butcher all along. His dynasty even boiled Koreans alive !

Genghis Khan wasn't even unusual for his age

---

When empires collapse, they usually become "vassals" of the successful powers around; the Muslims became vassals of the west in our time; especially the Arab countries, each western superpower has its vassals around the Middle East; and when one of the vassals "revolt" or "change loyalty" they get butchered, like Iraq during Saddam's reign.

Excuses Excuses 

[Angrboda]

The only constant in Winterhold's world is that it is always somebody else's fault. That's how he can avoid facing the fact that his ignorance, which is curable, remains unabated. He's just a lazy twat without any balls.