End Poverty with Vocations?!

[TrueChristian]

We know there is a lot of poverty in the USA.

It's a shame really. We have tried to help the poor for about 70 years with not a ton to show for it.

I have an idea though. Vocations!!  

What if in the despairing cities of Detroit, Milwaukee, North Minneapolis, Compton, South side of chicago etc. What if.. a flourishing of monastacism took place?

What if many young men and women were moved by the holy spirit ( Or Buddha I guess... ) to become monks and nuns? In the middle ages monks and nuns helped develop civilizaiton, by opening schools and researching medicine.

If young poor people in the USA were moved to become monks and nuns more, wouldn't that do a lot of good? Many people would be purged from wellfare roles ( the abbot/abbess would provide for them) but they would become sort of like social service workers themselves  

Moreover, since they would not reproduce, there wouldn't be as many out of wedlock babies  and things like that. The surplus population would decrease and there would be fewer mouths to feed.

Buddhist and Catholic monastries would indeed serve as a form of contraception that produces good fruit!

I am so excited.. I think  I have palpitations!!!

Well?

[Minimalist]

The last thing they need are more vacations.

[dyresand]

The last thing they need are more vacations.

I second that and also what about all those churches that pull millions of dollars why don't they help the poor 
or better yet why doesn't the church take in the poor and homeless helping them.

[Wyrd of Gawd]

We know there is a lot of poverty in the USA.

It's a shame really. We have tried to help the poor for about 70 years with not a ton to show for it.

I have an idea though. Vocations!!  

What if in the despairing cities of Detroit, Milwaukee, North Minneapolis, Compton, South side of chicago etc. What if.. a flourishing of monastacism took place?

What if many young men and women were moved by the holy spirit ( Or Buddha I guess... ) to become monks and nuns? In the middle ages monks and nuns helped develop civilizaiton, by opening schools and researching medicine.

If young poor people in the USA were moved to become monks and nuns more, wouldn't that do a lot of good? Many people would be purged from wellfare roles ( the abbot/abbess would provide for them) but they would become sort of like social service workers themselves  

Moreover, since they would not reproduce, there wouldn't be as many out of wedlock babies  and things like that. The surplus population would decrease and there would be fewer mouths to feed.

Buddhist and Catholic monastries would indeed serve as a form of contraception that produces good fruit!

I am so excited.. I think  I have palpitations!!!

Well?

Lead the way by becoming your first convert.  I'll even buy you a big wig so that you will feel important.

[Nay_Sayer]

Checkmate again TC.

Current score:

Me: 8 sets

You: 0

[Drich]

We know there is a lot of poverty in the USA.

It's a shame really. We have tried to help the poor for about 70 years with not a ton to show for it.

I have an idea though. Vocations!!  

What if in the despairing cities of Detroit, Milwaukee, North Minneapolis, Compton, South side of chicago etc. What if.. a flourishing of monastacism took place?

What if many young men and women were moved by the holy spirit ( Or Buddha I guess... ) to become monks and nuns? In the middle ages monks and nuns helped develop civilizaiton, by opening schools and researching medicine.

If young poor people in the USA were moved to become monks and nuns more, wouldn't that do a lot of good? Many people would be purged from wellfare roles ( the abbot/abbess would provide for them) but they would become sort of like social service workers themselves  

Moreover, since they would not reproduce, there wouldn't be as many out of wedlock babies  and things like that. The surplus population would decrease and there would be fewer mouths to feed.

Buddhist and Catholic monastries would indeed serve as a form of contraception that produces good fruit!

I am so excited.. I think  I have palpitations!!!

Well?

Have you ever tried to help someone who's Job is to be homeless or poor? I spent the first part of my Christian life doing this, and their is one thing I've learned.. That their is a freedom that the poor and homeless enjoy that most people with jobs will never truly understand. this freedom means more than life itself in some cases. This freedom however can not exist in any form of structured society. In essence the cost of this freedom is separation from any structured form of work or responsibility. As such you will NEVER talk someone into a job who sole purpose in life is to enjoy this 'freedom' for any length of time beyond what they have to do in order to get back to the 'freedom' they love.

[TrueChristian]

^ But there is enormous poverty in our inner cities. Don't you think if more inner city folks became monks and nuns, our sciety would be better off?

They at least wold be more likely to go to heaven!

[mediocrates]

[Drich]

^  But there is enormous poverty in our inner cities. Don't you think if more inner city folks became monks and nuns, our sciety would be better off?

They at least wold be more likely to go to heaven!

Not the issue. If people in the inner city (which is the focus of my ministry for 10+ years) do not want to take a full time job because it infringes on their 'freedom' from just a time perspective, (they would have less time to be involved with the things they would like to do with said freedom) then why would they swear an oath that would target and remove the behavior that they generally want to spend their 'freedom' doing?

The problem you don't seem to get is the poor and homeless for the most part choose to be that way because it affords them a lifestyle they want more than the conformity driven lifestyles all other social placements demand.

It is a completely different mind set, one you have to experience over a period of time to see and understand. Some members of society simply do not want to live a life that demands anything from them. for them it is preferable to be poor/homeless with their illusion of freedom, than to be rich, and tied to a job or responsibility.

[TrueChristian]

I suppose Im talking about it from a sociological persepctive. If poor people were joining convents and monastaries more, there would be less poor people