Is it bad that Muhammed(pbuh) married Aicha ?

[huss88ein]

Well I have been asked by a member about this and I told him that the age of marriage differ from time to time and from place to another .

If you ask me it is not unethical to get married if u reach the age of puberty for both sex and with of course the consent of the two people involved and their families.

And it is not just me saying that take a look at Texas law for example it says the same thing so why aren't they bad people.

http://statelaws.findlaw.com/texas-law/t...-laws.html

so the marriage issue is relative and not the same in everywhere and in islam it is the same thing but where judged and criticized because our law comes from a holy book .

[Longhorn]

I bet your objective morality told you that

[robvalue]

It's only a problem to those who claim there is objective morality.

[Homeless Nutter]

[...]
If you ask me it is not unethical to get married if u reach the age of puberty for both sex and with of course the consent of the two people involved and their families.
[...]

And I suppose - according to you - age of puberty for women is 6 years old, right? /smh
Go learn some elementary school biology.

[TubbyTubby]

Well I have been asked by a member about this and I told him that the age of marriage differ from time to time and from place to another .

so the marriage issue is relative and not the same in everywhere and in islam it is the same thing but where judged and criticized because our law comes from a holy book .

So if the marriage and particularly the consummation of marriage with 12 or 13 year old girls in Yemen is now considered repulsive and more importantly, proven to be dangerous to the girls health by most of civilised society, why doesn't someone change your fucked up 1400 year old book to reflect that?

Perhaps some dirty old men just like to feel justified while they fuck young children eh?

[huss88ein]

It's only a problem to those who claim there is objective morality.

Come on rob I already answered that in the ethics debate .

But anyway subjective morality is also acceptable in islam but this subjective morality can't attend to all the issues so we need objective morality too not that hard to understand.

And as the prophet(pbuh) said
I've been sent to continue

It's only a problem to those who claim there is objective morality.

Come on rob I already answered that in the ethics debate .

But anyway subjective morality is also acceptable in islam but this subjective morality can't attend to all the issues so we need objective morality too not that hard to understand.

And as the prophet(pbuh) said
"I was only sent to perfect good characters".

Not to make them but to perfect them .

[Longhorn]

Um, hussy.....things can't be simultaneously objective and subjective. That's kind of, you know, the core issue here.

[huss88ein]

[...]
If you ask me it is not unethical to get married if u reach the age of puberty for both sex and with of course the consent of the two people involved and their families.
[...]

And I suppose - according to you - age of puberty for women is 6 years old, right? /smh
Go learn some elementary school biology.

She was 9 at least and in other

[...]
If you ask me it is not unethical to get married if u reach the age of puberty for both sex and with of course the consent of the two people involved and their families.
[...]

And I suppose - according to you - age of puberty for women is 6 years old, right? /smh
Go learn some elementary school biology.

She was 9 at least when the marriage was consumated

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aisha

and yes I know biology and puberty differs and subject to many elements.

A question for u would marry a woman that is 15 years older than u ?

---

Um, hussy.....things can't be simultaneously objective and subjective. That's kind of, you know, the core issue here.

Have u read the hadith !!!!

If something is bad and u know it's bad it can never be accepted in islam but other things which are equally bad but can't be refused on a base of a rational deduction and that's how islam perfect characters and values in society .

---

Well I have been asked by a member about this and I told him that the age of marriage differ from time to time and from place to another .

so the marriage issue is relative and not the same in everywhere and in islam it is the same thing but where judged and criticized because our law comes from a holy book .

So if the marriage and particularly the consummation of marriage with 12 or 13 year old girls in Yemen is now considered repulsive and more importantly, proven to be dangerous to the girls health by most of civilised society, why doesn't someone change your fucked up 1400 year old book to reflect that?

Perhaps some dirty old men just like to feel justified while they fuck young children eh?

Ok I'm not here to defend countries but anyway how about texas ?

[Cato]

If you ask me it is not unethical to get married if u reach the age of puberty for both sex and with of course the consent of the two people involved and their families.

And it is not just me saying that take a look at Texas law for example it says the same thing so why aren't they bad people.

I'm interested in your definition of puberty as it pertains to a female child.

[huss88ein]

If you ask me it is not unethical to get married if u reach the age of puberty for both sex and with of course the consent of the two people involved and their families.

And it is not just me saying that take a look at Texas law for example it says the same thing so why aren't they bad people.

I'm interested in your definition of puberty as it pertains to a female child.

Girls reach puberty at the age of 10-11 in average .