Here's why Creatards might be right

[jenny1972]

Okay, we'll dive in...but full disclosure, photosynth is my living.  Firstly, again, this isn't a law of nature, so I won't be offering you any explanation as to a law of nature.  Secondly, it's not an example of organized behavior, it's not behavior at all.  It's the function of a specific type of cell - which a variety of behaviors are leveraged in support of (if you want an explanation of organized behaviors, it's all that stuff you're wondering about, not photosynthesis).  

Forget all that though....are we talking photosynthesis as in "what plants do", or the first ever?  I'm afraid that any answer I give you, btw, isn't going to be my personal theory, is that going to be a problem?

I can answer these:

do you believe it created itself , always existed , exc.

Without any elaboration, though.  No, I don't think that photosynthesis created itself, and no, I don't think that photosynthesis always existed.

if your knowledgeable about photosynthesis well just stick with that , the same principle can be applied to all complex behavior it doesnt matter what it is . were not looking for the explanation how it happens but the explanation how it came into existence , what created photosynthesis if not by intelligent design - not what the process involves .  the origin of it .