(December 3, 2015 at 4:56 pm)Stimbo Wrote: And that's my point. Do believers exercise the same critical thinking faculties on their own beliefs and personal experiences as everyone should do when confronted by a mystery, leap to the most fanciful explanation that seems to fit the facts, or simply be content with the mystery? As I said, what story would I have if I hadn't eliminated the mundane first? Or at all?
I can only speak for myself but yes I exercise critical thinking skills to rule out all plausible natural explanations. Though it also depends on the scenario. If I was in your scenario with a strange noise, maybe I wouldn't care what it was and not bother investigating and thus leaving it to mystery, but still I wouldn't assume supernatural. Supernatural is only something that cannot be explained by natural means.
If you hadn't investigated you could have contrived any sort of explanation you wanted, or none at all. It was important for you to discover the source and you found a plausible natural explanation. If you didn't go out of fear, you could have theorized any number of things from air vent expanding to aliens but it would be conjecture, nothing more.
We are not made happy by what we acquire but by what we appreciate.