My Rebuttal to Dawkins Argument

[Brakeman]

Now, clearly theists and atheist can agree on one thing: if anything at all exists, there must be something preceding it that always existed. How did this eternally existing reality come to be? The answer is that it never came to be. It always existed. Take your pick: God or universe. Something always existed

No. NO. No! The word "Always" has no meaning outside of time.

Let me say that a second time for you, The word "always" has no meaning outside of time and time began as matter began. There is no "before the singularity."

All of the existing, creating, and god magic occurred exactly 0.0000000 seconds before the universe existed, meaning it didn't happen.