(September 1, 2016 at 4:00 pm)Minimalist Wrote: Oddly, Stephen Colbert went looking to exactly where that tradition began. Like the pledge of allegiance with its 'under god' horseshit, it is not as old as you might think.
ESPN recently ran an article flushing out the 1918 World Series also. The song at the time was 'generally' popular, not to mention the impact of WWI on the sentiments of the general populous. I think the national anthem has its place and in certain circumstances can actually have a positive effect on solidarity in times of collective grief; e.g., post 9/11. Part of my disdain for its playing before every spectator sport is that it cheapens its meaning.
When I served, most people wouldn't be caught dead outside during colors to avoid standing at attention and saluting the flag for a couple moments. I honestly had no problem with it as it always served as a gentle reminder of the more important part of my then existence and sense of purpose outside the drudgery of the actual work involved.
The last bit here wasn't a reply to Min, but just providing some additional background. I am proud to be American, at least for the collective output worthy of praise, but my form of patriotism also makes me extremely critical because we could collectively do so much better. I still stand at attention when the anthem is played or the flag passes during a parade, but think the ubiquitous use of the anthem makes it routine and meaningless.
Perhaps another anecdote that gives additional understanding. This summer we took our six year old grandson to Sea World. During one of the shows they made a deal about veterans and asked us to stand up to be recognized for our service. I personally cringe at this type of display and don't participate more than clapping to show my appreciation for others that served. My wife understands my thoughts on the matter and no longer bothers me even though she disagrees. As everybody stood to get the obligatory round of applause my grandson loudly and excitedly states "Grandpa, you were in the Navy! You need to stand up!". Busted. My wife had a field day with that one.
