(March 6, 2017 at 5:30 pm)Simon Moon Wrote:(March 6, 2017 at 5:04 pm)Neo-Scholastic Wrote: There is only one proposition on the table. What is your stance with respect to P1, "God exists"? Either P1 is true or P1 is not true. As per the law of the excluded middle you have only two choices.
I agree, either P1 is true or not true. Those are the only possibilities.
My position on the truth values of P1 is, I don't know, with absolute certainty, if it is true or not. This defines me as agnostic.
My position on theist's claim that P1 is true, is I do not believe it, since I don't find that they have met their burden of proof. This defines me as an atheist.
But just because I do not believe gods exist, does not mean I am claiming that they don't exist. Only that I currently have no justification to believe they do.
I'm waiting for the day when option 3 arises... God used to exist but no longer does.