(August 5, 2011 at 3:39 pm)Statler Waldorf Wrote: I am well aware of the form of a disjunctive syllogism, I am not a moron:-P It’s easy to prove our arguments are completely opposite using the law of excluded middle. Either we live in a purely naturalistic universe, or we don't. It is that simple. If I can destroy the possibility of a naturalistic world, the supernatural exists by default. Once we admit the supernatural exists we can then move on to why it has to be a god, once we admit there has to be a god we can move on to why it has to be the God of scripture.
The original premise of the argument was that the Bible is a fantasy book, however if that is the line you wish to argue I'll happily admit that your disjunctive syllogism holds. I doubt you can prove we don't live in a purely naturalistic universe however, feel free to try. And remember: proofs need evidence. Good luck.
