RE: Coming to a mutual agreement and some rambling.
July 18, 2012 at 12:19 pm
(This post was last modified: July 18, 2012 at 12:29 pm by Mystic.)
I'm not saying you are not justified in Atheism.
I'm not stating you should become Theists.
I'm not stating Theists are justified in believing in God.
I'm saying there is no rational knock out argument to show either way.
Why? Because as far logical possibilities, then all are possible. This is different then actual possible.
Yes it doesn't mean because it is possible, that necessarily believers are justified in their belief. But just like I shouldn't be telling Atheists they should become Theists because I feel I know God exists, the same is true of the other way around, don't you guys agree? Because you feel you don't know God exists, doesn't mean a Theist should feel the same way necessarily. You maybe totally right that they shouldn't, but do you have proof and evidence?
If not, what's the point of asserting it constantly? Isn't it this what you dislike about Theists, is coming on here, asserting you should believe in God without proof?
All I'm saying, it's something people have to decide within. Hostility or constantly wanting to assert one's disbelief on others, doesn't come across well, and doesn't make you seem more logical, in the same way theists telling disbelievers they should believe and trying to assert their belief doesn't come across as logical.
I'm not stating you should become Theists.
I'm not stating Theists are justified in believing in God.
I'm saying there is no rational knock out argument to show either way.
Why? Because as far logical possibilities, then all are possible. This is different then actual possible.
Yes it doesn't mean because it is possible, that necessarily believers are justified in their belief. But just like I shouldn't be telling Atheists they should become Theists because I feel I know God exists, the same is true of the other way around, don't you guys agree? Because you feel you don't know God exists, doesn't mean a Theist should feel the same way necessarily. You maybe totally right that they shouldn't, but do you have proof and evidence?
If not, what's the point of asserting it constantly? Isn't it this what you dislike about Theists, is coming on here, asserting you should believe in God without proof?
All I'm saying, it's something people have to decide within. Hostility or constantly wanting to assert one's disbelief on others, doesn't come across well, and doesn't make you seem more logical, in the same way theists telling disbelievers they should believe and trying to assert their belief doesn't come across as logical.
