(October 4, 2009 at 8:29 am)Retorth Wrote: I already explained that if god gave us freewill, we should be allowed to decide for ourselves what we want, what we want to believe, how we want to lead our lives. That is the concept of freewill, is it not?
"made or done freely or of one's own accord; voluntary"
We should be free to choose, but this supposed god condemns us for not believing in him. This is why I say he is indecisive.
Well I've addressed these once and you ignored me. Let me try again then...
You're assuming 'God' and the Christian faith, which you at the same time deny. How can the conditions of a faith you deny have any bearing on you? You cannot conflate the two and criticise the position of belief from non belief. Either you criticise from the belief or you evaluate your own position from that position.
Where does God ever say our choice to disobey him will be to our benefit? To be indecisive he would have
to have said both. He never does. You do. You define free choice independently from God.
Second point ignored as it's completely irrelevant.
