(January 21, 2013 at 4:39 pm)AtlasS Wrote: there books came to be known as (the hadith books). They are written on asking people about what they heard, other than the quran.
that's the source of aisha being 9.
so, we can clearly say : the prediction of aisha's age came after 200 years, which makes it "very untrusted".
Does that mean when atheists are trying to discuss Islam with a Muslim we should find out what the Muslim concerned thinks about the hadith books?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadith
Quote:The largest denominations of Islam, Sunni, Shiʻa, and Ibadi, rely upon different sets of hadith collections.
Do you, personally, regard any of the sets of hadith collections as trustworthy. If so, why do you?
