(January 8, 2015 at 12:47 pm)robvalue Wrote: I'm not even getting to evidence, I'm seeing if someone can make a claim that makes sense and is testable.Yes, you are getting into evidence. I can't determine if a claim is consistent with what we know about reality unless you tell me how we know things about reality.
Quote:I'm not putting myself forward as an authority on what is and isn't a good claim,You're putting yourself forward as an authority on what we know about reality.
Quote:Do you have a claim?Again, I can't determine if a claim is consistent with what we know about reality unless you tell me how we know things about reality.