The right to mis-define oneself

[bennyboy]

You keep coming back to it like it fucking matters one bit, though. It's been your go to argument from the first. Like "for this reason, we shouldn't consider these people women." Disclosure is required for all people, if you have something to disclose. It doesn't matter what sex or gender you are.

We shouldn't consider them women, because they aren't women.  And we shouldn't redefine the word "woman," because it has a perfectly clear meaning already: a woman is an adult who was born with a vagina.  If a man wants to be called "Caitlyn," that's fine with me.  If he wants to be referred to as "she," that's fine with me.  But male is not female, and black is not white.

Disclosure is required IF you have something to disclose.  So if you are a woman, and you are with a man who expects to have sex with a woman, why would you need to disclose your penis?  Because it's the defining trait of manhood.