Open Letter To Christians

[Randy Carson]

Holocaust
Black Plague
Great Famine
Armenian Genocice
etc

All horrible events to be sure.

Tell me, nope, which of these things - which produced great suffering - would automatically endanger the immortal soul of one caught up in it?

None because you KNOW atheists don't accept a claim that a soul exists.

Not relevant.

First, atheists don't accept a claim that God exists, either. Consequently, citing the holocaust, etc. as evidence that God was not cited to anger is meaningless.

Second, if, for the sake of argument, you grant that God DOES exist, then you must also grant that He will behave in God-like ways and not in "Nope-like" ways. IOW, you can't say, "Well, God must not exist because He doesn't act like I want Him to act." If He exists, then He acts in ways that beyond our ways. Which includes being concerned about eternity and not about our fleeting moments on this earth.

So, again, don't argue that God must not exist because He does not act as you, mere human, might act.