Why make stupid unsustainable arguments?

[CapnAwesome]

I partially agree with the initial premises and conclusion - I've witnessed atheists present simplified, overly repeated arguments that offer no logical or rational discussion.

For sure, being an Atheist doesn't automatically grant anyone logic, rationality or the ability to coherently back up their arguments on an internet forum. If that's Aractus' complaint then you can only say: No shit.

The second part is if you are going to complain about something like this, you better be careful yourself. For example it's probably bad to then go into a bunch of personal theories that have scanty evidence, if any.

Edit: By you I don't mean you as in Dystopia, but refering to Aractus.