Posts: 2020
Threads: 133
Joined: July 26, 2017
Reputation:
5
What are the best arguments against Christian Science?
September 17, 2023 at 9:23 am
Christian Scientists believe that diseases are not caused by a physical abnormality, but by a mental error. In other words, that all diseases are psychosomatic. So they can be corrected by prayer alone. What do you think are the best arguments against that belief?
I found two arguments that sound good to me:
1) The poison argument. "Suppose somebody drinks a glass of water that contains a poison, but nobody knows that it is poisonous. If Christian Science is right, then that poison could not kill that person. If medical science is right, then it can kill that person. And it is obvious which is true."
2) The jellyfish argument. Jellyfish are animals without a brain, and therefore without a mind. If all diseases are psychosomatic, they could not get diseases such as cancer. But they do get them.
Do you know some more?
Posts: 1988
Threads: 93
Joined: October 23, 2022
Reputation:
8
RE: What are the best arguments against Christian Science?
September 17, 2023 at 9:33 am
(September 17, 2023 at 9:23 am)FlatAssembler Wrote: Christian Scientists believe that diseases are not caused by a physical abnormality, but by a mental error. In other words, that all diseases are psychosomatic. So they can be corrected by prayer alone. What do you think are the best arguments against that belief?
I think the Christian Scientists are on to something. Twelve years ago I had stage III inflammatory breast cancer with a prognosis of only a 25-40 percent chance of living another five years. My mother began to pray the rosary times without number, and soon after my chemo and mastectomy the cancer went away!
Posts: 28442
Threads: 525
Joined: June 16, 2015
Reputation:
90
RE: What are the best arguments against Christian Science?
September 17, 2023 at 9:38 am
(This post was last modified: September 17, 2023 at 9:39 am by brewer.)
never mind, it's early and I've not had my coffee
Being told you're delusional does not necessarily mean you're mental.
Posts: 2020
Threads: 133
Joined: July 26, 2017
Reputation:
5
RE: What are the best arguments against Christian Science?
September 17, 2023 at 10:17 am
(September 17, 2023 at 9:33 am)LinuxGal Wrote: (September 17, 2023 at 9:23 am)FlatAssembler Wrote: Christian Scientists believe that diseases are not caused by a physical abnormality, but by a mental error. In other words, that all diseases are psychosomatic. So they can be corrected by prayer alone. What do you think are the best arguments against that belief?
I think the Christian Scientists are on to something. Twelve years ago I had stage III inflammatory breast cancer with a prognosis of only a 25-40 percent chance of living another five years. My mother began to pray the rosary times without number, and soon after my chemo and mastectomy the cancer went away!
I am sorry about that.
Posts: 1988
Threads: 93
Joined: October 23, 2022
Reputation:
8
RE: What are the best arguments against Christian Science?
September 17, 2023 at 10:21 am
(September 17, 2023 at 10:17 am)FlatAssembler Wrote: (September 17, 2023 at 9:33 am)LinuxGal Wrote: I think the Christian Scientists are on to something. Twelve years ago I had stage III inflammatory breast cancer with a prognosis of only a 25-40 percent chance of living another five years. My mother began to pray the rosary times without number, and soon after my chemo and mastectomy the cancer went away!
I am sorry about that.
If you're gonna get cancer the 21st Century is a better time to get it. In the 1990s or earlier I woulda been dead meat.
Posts: 29865
Threads: 116
Joined: February 22, 2011
Reputation:
159
RE: What are the best arguments against Christian Science?
September 17, 2023 at 10:25 am
(September 17, 2023 at 9:23 am)FlatAssembler Wrote: Christian Scientists believe that diseases are not caused by a physical abnormality, but by a mental error. In other words, that all diseases are psychosomatic. So they can be corrected by prayer alone. What do you think are the best arguments against that belief?
I found two arguments that sound good to me:
1) The poison argument. "Suppose somebody drinks a glass of water that contains a poison, but nobody knows that it is poisonous. If Christian Science is right, then that poison could not kill that person. If medical science is right, then it can kill that person. And it is obvious which is true."
2) The jellyfish argument. Jellyfish are animals without a brain, and therefore without a mind. If all diseases are psychosomatic, they could not get diseases such as cancer. But they do get them.
Do you know some more?
Posts: 46443
Threads: 541
Joined: July 24, 2013
Reputation:
109
RE: What are the best arguments against Christian Science?
September 17, 2023 at 1:27 pm
(This post was last modified: September 17, 2023 at 3:42 pm by BrianSoddingBoru4.)
I think a plausible case could be made against Christian Science by beating the living daylights out of a Christian Scientist. Since they believe that the material world is purely illusory, they wouldn’t be able to file an assault charge against me. Their broken teeth and severe contusions and blood loss didn’t really happen.
Boru
‘I can’t be having with this.’ - Esmeralda Weatherwax
Posts: 19789
Threads: 57
Joined: September 24, 2010
Reputation:
85
RE: What are the best arguments against Christian Science?
September 17, 2023 at 6:47 pm
(September 17, 2023 at 10:25 am)Angrboda Wrote: (September 17, 2023 at 9:23 am)FlatAssembler Wrote: Christian Scientists believe that diseases are not caused by a physical abnormality, but by a mental error. In other words, that all diseases are psychosomatic. So they can be corrected by prayer alone. What do you think are the best arguments against that belief?
I found two arguments that sound good to me:
1) The poison argument. "Suppose somebody drinks a glass of water that contains a poison, but nobody knows that it is poisonous. If Christian Science is right, then that poison could not kill that person. If medical science is right, then it can kill that person. And it is obvious which is true."
2) The jellyfish argument. Jellyfish are animals without a brain, and therefore without a mind. If all diseases are psychosomatic, they could not get diseases such as cancer. But they do get them.
Do you know some more?
Amazing a robot evaluates and select response options based on reading these options writing out in English and projected onto inputs of its optical sensors, like there was some literate gremlin operating via a VR headset.
Posts: 19789
Threads: 57
Joined: September 24, 2010
Reputation:
85
RE: What are the best arguments against Christian Science?
September 17, 2023 at 6:49 pm
(September 17, 2023 at 9:23 am)FlatAssembler Wrote: Christian Scientists believe that diseases are not caused by a physical abnormality, but by a mental error. In other words, that all diseases are psychosomatic. So they can be corrected by prayer alone. What do you think are the best arguments against that belief?
I found two arguments that sound good to me:
1) The poison argument. "Suppose somebody drinks a glass of water that contains a poison, but nobody knows that it is poisonous. If Christian Science is right, then that poison could not kill that person. If medical science is right, then it can kill that person. And it is obvious which is true."
2) The jellyfish argument. Jellyfish are animals without a brain, and therefore without a mind. If all diseases are psychosomatic, they could not get diseases such as cancer. But they do get them.
Do you know some more?
Require all Christian scientists to rely purely on mental correctness and the question of whether christIan scenarists are right would become irrelevant in a couple of generations.
|