Posts: 29101
Threads: 218
Joined: August 9, 2014
Reputation:
154
RE: How to debunk the first cause argument without trying too hard
September 20, 2015 at 9:53 am
(This post was last modified: September 20, 2015 at 10:05 am by robvalue.)
Either there are things which need no creator, or there are not.
If there are such things, we can't rule out the universe being one of them. Examining things inside the universe gives no indication as to the created status of the universe itself. We have no created or non-created universe to compare it to.
If there are no such things, then God isn't either and we have infinite regression.
I think the reason theists aren't bothered by the idea of God needing a creator is because it never makes any kind of appearance except as a concept. If we could examine it in any way, the same questions would start popping up, and we've just moved the problem one place backwards. For example, if this is a computer simulation, God is a computer or a programmer. You now want to know where his reality came from, right?
You can't just define paradox answers into existence and claim that is sufficient. You still have to establish first the possibility such a thing can exist, and then even better some evidence that it does actually exist. This is all beyond the scope of mere philosophy.
And there is no paradox, it's just insisted that there is, so that a logical "only way to fix it" can be defined into existence.
The universe always existing is perfectly consistent. I'm not saying it has always been there, I'm saying we have no way or knowing whether it has or not.
Having said that, I really don't give a shit and you can have a deistic creator for free. You have all your work ahead of you trying to make it match a story book. It just so happens these first cause arguments are terrible. For starters, how did you rule out a computer simulation and the infinite number of possible deistic "god"s? Even after you did that, how did you shortlist the infinite number of interventionist gods to story books that happen to be lying around? And even then... you've got to convince me why I should care at all.
Posts: 11260
Threads: 61
Joined: January 5, 2013
Reputation:
123
RE: How to debunk the first cause argument without trying too hard
September 20, 2015 at 11:22 am
(September 20, 2015 at 8:57 am)ChadWooters Wrote: The skeptic has no interest in developing their own consistent philosophy. They just want to tear down your ideas and walk away smirking.
Yes, because you'd never sink that low, would you Chad?
Also, please don't mistake being unconcerned over your undemonstrated but shrilly asserted god claims with not having a consistent philosophy. An effective view of the world doesn't get hung up over fiat claims, nor is it uncomfortable in simply acknowledging those areas where we don't know everything yet. In fact, both of those things are what lead to this willingness to tear down flatly asserted ideas like "atheism is nihilism," or Kalam, or whatever special pleading or baseless dismissals you feel like bringing to bear on the responses to it, because that philosophy recognizes the harm that religious logic can bring.
We point out that you're dulling your knife with such fallacious logic, your only response is to claim we have no knife at all, and yet you accuse us of only tearing down your ideas?
"YOU take the hard look in the mirror. You are everything that is wrong with this world. The only thing important to you, is you." - ronedee
Want to see more of my writing? Check out my (safe for work!) site, Unprotected Sects!
Posts: 8214
Threads: 394
Joined: November 2, 2011
Reputation:
44
RE: How to debunk the first cause argument without trying too hard
September 20, 2015 at 11:42 am
I've dealt with the no before time contention before. It doesn't do away with the past being finite, and there needing to be an eternal non-finite cause. The universe was obviously not in in eternal state from this perspective but started at time zero be there a before or no before that. Therefore it's not logical to state it caused itself.
Posts: 35365
Threads: 122
Joined: February 22, 2011
Reputation:
159
RE: How to debunk the first cause argument without trying too hard
September 20, 2015 at 12:13 pm
(This post was last modified: September 20, 2015 at 12:15 pm by Angrboda.)
(September 20, 2015 at 8:57 am)ChadWooters Wrote: The "What caused God" objection is indeed inane. Any atheist who raises it demonstrates their own ignorance. The problem with it; however, is that the objection presupposes so many other things. A recalcitrant skeptic can just keep retreating into a brier patch of modern analytic dilemmas. The skeptic has no interest in developing their own consistent philosophy. They just want to tear down your ideas and walk away smirking.
Oh boo hoo. Skepticism, since the ancient Greeks, has been about showing the holes in seemingly solid edifices. That's what skepticism is. If your complaint is that there aren't more system builders among atheists, say so. That puts the question of whose values are at stake here more plainly, they're yours. You are disturbed that there aren't more atheists who, like you, care about philosophical systems. Well that's not just atheists, the world of philosophy has moved on from the system building era, because it only produced cracked edifices. Your special interest is that you feel a certain discarded edifice can rescue your God. How many atheists do you expect to share your interest in that? You're being silly. Expecting others to share your concern over system building when it's not motivated by a concern for system building at all, but is a religiously motivated concern, is ridiculous.
Posts: 11260
Threads: 61
Joined: January 5, 2013
Reputation:
123
RE: How to debunk the first cause argument without trying too hard
September 20, 2015 at 12:33 pm
(September 20, 2015 at 11:42 am)MysticKnight Wrote: I've dealt with the no before time contention before. It doesn't do away with the past being finite, and there needing to be an eternal non-finite cause.
Sure it does. If there's no before time, then the notion of cause and effect need not be applied. You're essentially saying that the notion that there is no "before" time began is irrelevant because you'd still need something before time.
Quote:The universe was obviously not in in eternal state from this perspective but started at time zero be there a before or no before that. Therefore it's not logical to state it caused itself.
What are you basing that on? The current science states that we'd need an entirely new set of physics and languages before we can even begin to approach what stuff was like at the Planck time and potentially prior to it, but you have some special knowledge about what could or could not cause our current universe at that time? How's that?
"YOU take the hard look in the mirror. You are everything that is wrong with this world. The only thing important to you, is you." - ronedee
Want to see more of my writing? Check out my (safe for work!) site, Unprotected Sects!
Posts: 8719
Threads: 128
Joined: March 1, 2012
Reputation:
53
RE: How to debunk the first cause argument without trying too hard
September 20, 2015 at 1:35 pm
(This post was last modified: September 20, 2015 at 1:39 pm by Neo-Scholastic.)
(September 20, 2015 at 11:22 am)Esquilax Wrote: ...your undemonstrated but shrilly asserted god claims with not having a consistent philosophy. Shrill? That's quite hyperbolic in the current thread.
(September 20, 2015 at 11:22 am)Esquilax Wrote: An effective view of the world doesn't get hung up over fiat claims... I agree. That is why I avoid them.
(September 20, 2015 at 11:22 am)Esquilax Wrote: ... flatly asserted ideas like "atheism is nihilism," or Kalam,..
I publicly retracted the blanket statement that atheism is nihilism. You were there. To bring it up is unfair. Since then I have been careful to quality atheistic positions like physical monism and ontological naturalism.
Second, I never defended the Kalam argument. It is not well formulated. I do support the 'five ways' of Aquinas, which are different. You should know. You claimed they were trivially easy to refute. You said you would write a blog post demonstrating such. I speculated that they would do no such thing. You accused me of putting words in your mouth. I invited you to share your completed blog posts with everyone and promised to publicly apologize if your arguments did not match my speculations. You have not yet done so.
My guess is that refuting Aquinas is not as trivially easy as you asserted by fiat.
Posts: 8214
Threads: 394
Joined: November 2, 2011
Reputation:
44
RE: How to debunk the first cause argument without trying too hard
September 20, 2015 at 1:41 pm
There is no changing that time is finite. There being no before time, doesn't make the universe eternal then transient/finite. It means it's finite but to talk about before it doesn't make sense if it's the first thing created, since time is the measurement of before and after, but it still requires eternal being bringing it into existence since it wasn't always there whether or not you can apply before to it or not.
Posts: 8719
Threads: 128
Joined: March 1, 2012
Reputation:
53
RE: How to debunk the first cause argument without trying too hard
September 20, 2015 at 1:55 pm
(This post was last modified: September 20, 2015 at 2:41 pm by Neo-Scholastic.
Edit Reason: grammar
)
(September 20, 2015 at 12:13 pm)Jörmungandr Wrote: Skepticism, since the ancient Greeks, has been about showing the holes in seemingly solid edifices. That's what skepticism is. Modern skeptics are a different breed. They are just closed-minded nay-sayers. That is NOT a generalization of atheists.
(September 20, 2015 at 12:13 pm)Jörmungandr Wrote: If your complaint is that there aren't more system builders among atheists, say so. My complaint is specific to the 'What Caused God' objection. It is a knee-jerk response that carries with it a whole set of misunderstandings about ontological claims.
(September 20, 2015 at 12:13 pm)Jörmungandr Wrote: You are disturbed that there aren't more atheists who, like you, care about philosophical systems. Not particularly. Most people really do not care to study philosophy or spend much time thinking about it. I only ask that when people do engage in philosophy, they should at least make the effort to be internally consistent and not simply present arguments of convenience.
(September 20, 2015 at 12:13 pm)Jörmungandr Wrote: ...the world of philosophy has moved on from the system building era, because it only produced cracked edifices. So your solution is to give up because the task is hard?
(September 20, 2015 at 12:13 pm)Jörmungandr Wrote: Expecting others to share your concern over system building when it's not motivated by a concern for system building at all, but is a religiously motivated concern, is ridiculous. My motivation is to know and live by the truth. You may not believe that but that is how I think. At one time reason prompted me to adopt an atheist position. Further inquiry has lead me to believe in God. Maybe that too will change, but for now that reflects my best understanding.
Posts: 35365
Threads: 122
Joined: February 22, 2011
Reputation:
159
RE: How to debunk the first cause argument without trying too hard
September 20, 2015 at 6:17 pm
(September 20, 2015 at 1:55 pm)ChadWooters Wrote: (September 20, 2015 at 12:13 pm)Jörmungandr Wrote: If your complaint is that there aren't more system builders among atheists, say so. My complaint is specific to the 'What Caused God' objection. It is a knee-jerk response that carries with it a whole set of misunderstandings about ontological claims.
Well, that really is the main problem, most definitions of the ontology of God are just claims, lacking support.
(September 20, 2015 at 1:55 pm)ChadWooters Wrote: (September 20, 2015 at 12:13 pm)Jörmungandr Wrote: ...the world of philosophy has moved on from the system building era, because it only produced cracked edifices. So your solution is to give up because the task is hard?
More like giving up fruitless avenues of research to concentrate on those that yield results.
(September 20, 2015 at 1:55 pm)ChadWooters Wrote: (September 20, 2015 at 12:13 pm)Jörmungandr Wrote: Expecting others to share your concern over system building when it's not motivated by a concern for system building at all, but is a religiously motivated concern, is ridiculous. My motivation is to know and live by the truth. You may not believe that but that is how I think. At one time reason prompted me to adopt an atheist position. Further inquiry has lead me to believe in God. Maybe that too will change, but for now that reflects my best understanding.
Fair enough. I do likewise and pursue materialist explanations because they are more definitive. I feel that you have given up on material explanations prematurely. Coming up with materialist explanations is hard, but it isn't fruitless.
Posts: 49
Threads: 0
Joined: August 23, 2015
Reputation:
1
RE: How to debunk the first cause argument without trying too hard
September 21, 2015 at 1:55 am
|