Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: November 17, 2026, 7:40 am

Thread Rating:
  • 1 Vote(s) - 5 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic
RE: Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic
Was there a before?
I am the Infantry. I am my country’s strength in war, her deterrent in peace. I am the heart of the fight… wherever, whenever. I carry America’s faith and honor against her enemies. I am the Queen of Battle. I am what my country expects me to be, the best trained Soldier in the world. In the race for victory, I am swift, determined, and courageous, armed with a fierce will to win. Never will I fail my country’s trust. Always I fight on…through the foe, to the objective, to triumph overall. If necessary, I will fight to my death. By my steadfast courage, I have won more than 200 years of freedom. I yield not to weakness, to hunger, to cowardice, to fatigue, to superior odds, For I am mentally tough, physically strong, and morally straight. I forsake not, my country, my mission, my comrades, my sacred duty. I am relentless. I am always there, now and forever. I AM THE INFANTRY! FOLLOW ME!
Reply
RE: Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic
(April 2, 2018 at 6:07 pm)Khemikal Wrote: Was there a before?

Duh. But Steve has no idea what it really was like then, I do. AMA
"For the only way to eternal glory is a life lived in service of our Lord, FSM; Verily it is FSM who is the perfect being the name higher than all names, king of all kings and will bestow upon us all, one day, The great reclaiming"  -The Prophet Boiardi-

   
  Conservative trigger warning.
[Image: s-l640.jpg][Image: shopping?q=tbn:ANd9GcSBjdQ4tzp0y16OBYXxG...s&usqp=CAc]
                                                                                         
Reply
RE: Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic
(March 27, 2018 at 8:59 am)possibletarian Wrote:
(March 26, 2018 at 3:03 pm)SteveII Wrote: There is no category error because only you are limiting the premise to be material things. There are a large number of things that do no have material causes:

1. The thing that makes you "you".
2. Mathematical objects.
3. Ideas, novels, and symphonies
4. Language
5. Classes, properties, descriptions

How many of these exist apart from our material universe ?

Round about...... none of them.

(March 27, 2018 at 11:24 am)SteveII Wrote: So, if we can't conceive of such a reality, why would we deny the premise "anything that begins to exist has a cause" is a lot more likely true than not?

Everything that begins to exist does have a cause... but there's absolutely no reason for the first cause to be God.

And, furthermore, the totality of existence itself doesn't begin to exist. It is the first cause, if causality (or anything) is going to make sense at all.

What has this got to do with disproving Odin by the way?
Reply
RE: Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic
Reply
RE: Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic
(March 28, 2018 at 2:16 pm)Neo-Scholastic Wrote: That’s true the elephant did not begin to exist until some matter took the form of an elephant. But the elephant’s existence is more than just the matter of which it is made. In fact, the matter out of which it is made will change as the elephant grows from conception through its maturity. And upon death the matter will remain even after the elephant has ceased to exist. That’s all we have been saying. The existence of the elephant began at some point and ended at some later point.

Any theory of existence must account for something, like an elephant, to persist in its existence despite undergoing change. Limiting yourself to only material and efficient causes cannot account for either.

Unfortunately, that’s all I have time for today, JennyA. I wish I had time to explain more about intelligible objects.

But the elephant consists of nothing other than the matter of which it is made and the processes that this matter undergoes. Your argument is, at the extreme, a version of the Ship of Theseus. It is a matter of our classification and the continuity of causal links rather than anything inherent in the object itself.

Again, Aristotelian philosophy was a good beginning, but it is outdated. We have learned a few things in the last 2300 years.

My basic position is that everything supervenes on the physical: once we know everything about the physical situation, we know everything there is to know. So, ideas are processes in our physical brains, with commonality between brains sufficient to say when two different brains have the 'same idea'. Conventions and language are, again, shared ideas in the brains of people holding to those conventions or languages. Mathematics is a type of formal language and, again, is a common set of ideas shared and hence ultimately supervenes on the physical.

The notions of causality in Aritotelianism are also outdated. For one thing, final causes only eists when there are minds that can plan. So the vast majority of things do not have final causes at all. Formal causes are simply shapes and not reasonably called causes at all. Material causes are, in essence, simply composition, and are again not really causes at all. So efficient causes are the only aspect that is close to something meaningful at all.

But the problem is that there are usually several contributory causes, not a single efficient cause. Furthermore, it is quite possible for the full collection of contributory causes to be insufficient for the event to occur. There is, in addition to any causes, a further randomness in the universe which is non-causal in nature. So, the idea that everything *must* have a cause is faulty. If your 'reason' dictates that everything that begins to exist must have a cause, then your reason is faulty and needs to be brought up to date with modern discoveries.
Reply
RE: Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic
(April 1, 2018 at 1:38 pm)Raven Orlock Wrote: My ex-wife claimed that Odin spoke to her in late May 2011. From that point, she started losing weight and got a tattoo and started smoking because she claimed that Odin said she needs to be her real person. Ugh, she couldn't lose weight and put a cute dress on for me, she had to do it for some imaginary friend.

Have you considered wearing an eye patch and getting a couple of pet ravens?   Tongue
Reply
RE: Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic
Odin would kick all other gods asses.
Reply
RE: Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic
(April 2, 2018 at 6:06 pm)SteveII Wrote:
(March 31, 2018 at 3:01 am)Jenny A Wrote: Quantum level particles.

RR already responded to this silly example that keeps coming up over and over and over:

Quote:Quantum mechanics merely describe what takes place at the quantum level.  It makes no reference to causes, but that does not imply that there are no causal entities involved.
Feser hypothesizes that perhaps Oerter understands the law of causality to refer to some sort of deterministic cause, and since quantum mechanics are supposedly indeterministic (a disputed interpretation), the law of causality could not apply.  Feser notes that “[t]he principle of causality doesn’t require that.  It requires only that a potency be actualized by something already actual; whether that something, whatever it is, actualizes potencies according some sort of pattern –deterministic or otherwise — is another matter altogether.”

The fact of the matter is that quantum mechanics has not identified causeless effects or invalidated the causal principle.  For any event to occur it must first have the potential to occur, and then have that potential actualized.  If that potential is actualized, it “must be actualized by something already actual,”[2] and that something is what we identify as the cause. https://theosophical.wordpress.com/2012/...principle/

Quote:But  setting that aside, each of my categories has a different kind of cause.  Placing the universe in the right category tells you what kind of cause to look for.  If the universe physically exists, you need a physical cause.  If it began to exist before time and space, than "cause" makes no sense. Cause and effect requires time.

First, notice that you are invoking a causal principle for the universe (in bold). You have just agreed with Premise 1. You seem to be objecting to PRem

Second, cause and effect do not require time. If anything, matter/motion/change is needed for time to exist (if not the cause of time itself). 

Third, you are right, saying that the universe began to exist before time and space makes not sense. That's why we don't say that. When the universe began to exist, so would time--simultaneously. 

Fourth, at some point, you run out of physical causes as you go back because it is impossible for there to have been an infinite amount of causes that have already elapsed in order to get to the start of our universe.

Quote:Rather than complain about my analysing what is meant by existence, I suggest YOU define it for purposes of the KCA. 

And, yes, there are things that happen at the quantum level that appear to be without cause.  Before your first premise  can be accepted, you'll need to explain quantum level causation.


Are you being deliberately obtuse?  The point is not when, but what counts as beginning to exist.  An elephant is born out of existing matter.  Other than those quantum particles you keep ignoring, what do you know of that is ever made without preexisting material?  I don't think anything made out of stuff already in existence can be compared to the appearance of new things not made out of preexisting stuff. Why should we make that leap?

Something begins to exist when it becomes more than just its component parts and/or separate from the cause of its existence. An elephant begins to exist when takes shape in the womb. A chair becomes a chair when it can serve the purpose of a chair. An idea begins to exist when it has sufficient content to convey meaning. Arguing about stages of completion is semantics and entirely subjective. The principle is always there--at one point you didn't have x and and another point you obviously have x. 

Regarding your "preexisting stuff" and "leap", we are very clearly talking about prior to the universe. Why would we limit ourselves to a component of the causal principle that very obviously has to do with the atoms and molecules within our universe. Imposing a material cause restriction when there are many examples of things that do not have material causes is not justifiable. Additionally, through inductive reasoning, we can clearly see that an infinite chain of material causes is impossible. There is no such thing as an actual infinite by successive addition. There must be an immaterial cause at some point in the past chain.  

Quote:The universe is material.  Name a single material thing without a material  cause. Hint, there are those pesky particles.  But if you ignore them, then we are back to all material things need a material cause.

Again with the "in the universe" restrictions. The conversation is about before the universe.

I think the following article is relevant, but I haven't backtracked through your argument with Jenny here to be sure. Regardless, I think it's worth your time.

Craig, Kalam, and Quantum Mechanics: Has Craig Defeated the Quantum Mechanics Objection to the Causal Principle?
[Image: extraordinarywoo-sig.jpg?rlkey=x1nmxbwrp...pouidnfvtl]
Reply
RE: Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic
(May 29, 2018 at 11:02 am)Jörmungandr Wrote:
(April 2, 2018 at 6:06 pm)SteveII Wrote: RR already responded to this silly example that keeps coming up over and over and over:



First, notice that you are invoking a causal principle for the universe (in bold). You have just agreed with Premise 1. You seem to be objecting to PRem

Second, cause and effect do not require time. If anything, matter/motion/change is needed for time to exist (if not the cause of time itself). 

Third, you are right, saying that the universe began to exist before time and space makes not sense. That's why we don't say that. When the universe began to exist, so would time--simultaneously. 

Fourth, at some point, you run out of physical causes as you go back because it is impossible for there to have been an infinite amount of causes that have already elapsed in order to get to the start of our universe.


Something begins to exist when it becomes more than just its component parts and/or separate from the cause of its existence. An elephant begins to exist when takes shape in the womb. A chair becomes a chair when it can serve the purpose of a chair. An idea begins to exist when it has sufficient content to convey meaning. Arguing about stages of completion is semantics and entirely subjective. The principle is always there--at one point you didn't have x and and another point you obviously have x. 

Regarding your "preexisting stuff" and "leap", we are very clearly talking about prior to the universe. Why would we limit ourselves to a component of the causal principle that very obviously has to do with the atoms and molecules within our universe. Imposing a material cause restriction when there are many examples of things that do not have material causes is not justifiable. Additionally, through inductive reasoning, we can clearly see that an infinite chain of material causes is impossible. There is no such thing as an actual infinite by successive addition. There must be an immaterial cause at some point in the past chain.  


Again with the "in the universe" restrictions. The conversation is about before the universe.

I think the following article is relevant, but I haven't backtracked through your argument with Jenny here to be sure.  Regardless, I think it's worth your time.

Craig, Kalam, and Quantum Mechanics: Has Craig Defeated the Quantum Mechanics Objection to the Causal Principle?
Good article 

But Steve is committed to spewing Craigs nonsense till death .Because actual physics creates problems for his fables .
Seek strength, not to be greater than my brother, but to fight my greatest enemy -- myself.

Inuit Proverb

Reply
RE: Disproving Odin - An Experiment in arguing with a theist with Theist logic
(May 29, 2018 at 11:02 am)Jörmungandr Wrote:
(April 2, 2018 at 6:06 pm)SteveII Wrote: RR already responded to this silly example that keeps coming up over and over and over:



First, notice that you are invoking a causal principle for the universe (in bold). You have just agreed with Premise 1. You seem to be objecting to PRem

Second, cause and effect do not require time. If anything, matter/motion/change is needed for time to exist (if not the cause of time itself). 

Third, you are right, saying that the universe began to exist before time and space makes not sense. That's why we don't say that. When the universe began to exist, so would time--simultaneously. 

Fourth, at some point, you run out of physical causes as you go back because it is impossible for there to have been an infinite amount of causes that have already elapsed in order to get to the start of our universe.


Something begins to exist when it becomes more than just its component parts and/or separate from the cause of its existence. An elephant begins to exist when takes shape in the womb. A chair becomes a chair when it can serve the purpose of a chair. An idea begins to exist when it has sufficient content to convey meaning. Arguing about stages of completion is semantics and entirely subjective. The principle is always there--at one point you didn't have x and and another point you obviously have x. 

Regarding your "preexisting stuff" and "leap", we are very clearly talking about prior to the universe. Why would we limit ourselves to a component of the causal principle that very obviously has to do with the atoms and molecules within our universe. Imposing a material cause restriction when there are many examples of things that do not have material causes is not justifiable. Additionally, through inductive reasoning, we can clearly see that an infinite chain of material causes is impossible. There is no such thing as an actual infinite by successive addition. There must be an immaterial cause at some point in the past chain.  


Again with the "in the universe" restrictions. The conversation is about before the universe.

I think the following article is relevant, but I haven't backtracked through your argument with Jenny here to be sure.  Regardless, I think it's worth your time.

Craig, Kalam, and Quantum Mechanics: Has Craig Defeated the Quantum Mechanics Objection to the Causal Principle?
I am going to cite Betteridge. Any headline ending with a question mark is sufficiently answered by the word "No".
Reply



Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  It's Darwin Day tomorrow - logic and reason demands merriment! Duty 7 2141 February 13, 2022 at 10:21 am
Last Post: BrianSoddingBoru4
Photo The atrocities of religiosity warrant our finest. Logic is not it Ghetto Sheldon 86 21194 October 5, 2021 at 8:41 pm
Last Post: Rahn127
  Neil DeGrasse Tyson on Disproving God Mechaghostman2 158 64719 July 14, 2021 at 3:52 pm
Last Post: awty
  First order logic, set theory and God dr0n3 293 93851 December 11, 2018 at 11:35 am
Last Post: T0 Th3 M4X
  Disproving the christian (and muslim) god I_am_not_mafia 106 53320 March 15, 2018 at 6:57 pm
Last Post: The Grand Nudger
  a challenge All atheists There is inevitably a Creator. Logic says that suni_muslim 65 30493 November 28, 2017 at 5:02 pm
Last Post: Fidel_Castronaut
  What is logic? Little Rik 278 125413 May 1, 2017 at 5:40 pm
Last Post: Cyberman
  What is your Opinion on Having Required Classes in Logic in Schools? Salacious B. Crumb 43 18212 August 4, 2015 at 12:01 am
Last Post: BitchinHitchins
  Arguing w/ Religious Friends z7z 14 6359 June 5, 2015 at 4:53 pm
Last Post: Cephus
  Logic vs Evidence dimaniac 34 19729 November 25, 2014 at 10:41 pm
Last Post: bennyboy



Users browsing this thread: 10 Guest(s)