Anti Trans And Why It Fails

[no one]

Maketakunai:
Make stop use wurdz so big. Head hurtz. Mi dikshunary no go to this wurdz. No be meen. 

[Amarok]

Maketakunai:
Make stop use wurdz so big. Head hurtz. Mi dikshunary no go to this wurdz. No be meen. 

Careful or he will launch into a paragraph long spaz attack on you .

[Gwaithmir]

I had a transsexual girlfriend during the late 1980's and early 1990's and never thought of her as anything other than a woman.

[Amarok]

I had a transsexual girlfriend during the late 1980's and early 1990's and never thought of her as anything other than a woman.

Aww that's sweet

[Rev. Rye]

Gender is defined by gentiles????



And here I was, thinking it was the Jews....



Silly me.

And this is where I'd show a clip of that episode of South Park where the Japanese girls make Tweek and Craig gay, specifically the scene where Stan is talking about Randy about homosexuality, and Randy says "The Asian? The Asians decide who's going to be gay? Uh are y-, yeah, yeah they do. Uh, the Asians just, you know, the Asians pick who they pick, and um, it's al- it's, the way it's always been."

Sadly, I can't find that clip on Youtube.

Also, I'm going to have to call bullshit on Tizh's claim that it took 20 minutes for him to figure out he fucked up the spelling of "genitals." I mean, as much as I hate the 2-hour edit window we have, if it was just 20 minutes, he still could have rectified the issue. Maybe 20 minutes after he responded to that post, he figured it out, but not 20 minutes after the first post. Unless that's what he meant all along, in which case, I retract my bullshit calling and replace it with a "maybe you should have been clearer on that point."

Still, apart from that, the OP is fairly well argued.

[Amarok]

Gender is defined by gentiles????



And here I was, thinking it was the Jews....



Silly me.

And this is where I'd show a clip of that episode of South Park where the Japanese girls make Tweek and Craig gay, specifically the scene where Stan is talking about Randy about homosexuality, and Randy says "The Asian? The Asians decide who's going to be gay? Uh are y-, yeah, yeah they do. Uh, the Asians just, you know, the Asians pick who they pick, and um, it's al- it's, the way it's always been."

Sadly, I can't find that clip on Youtube.  

Also, I'm going to have to call bullshit on Tizh's claim that it took 20 minutes for him to figure out he fucked up the spelling of "genitals." I mean, as much as I hate the 2-hour edit window we have, if it was just 20 minutes, he still could have rectified the issue. Maybe 20 minutes after he responded to that post, he figured it out, but not 20 minutes after the first post. Unless that's what he meant all along, in which case, I retract my bullshit calling and replace it with a "maybe you should have been clearer on that point."

Still, apart from that, the OP is fairly well argued.

I mean 20 minutes  after I logged on again and reread the post I was gone for 3 hours after I posted it

[Rev. Rye]

Good point. Then this should have been your response:



Also, looking closely at this screenshot, am I the only one to notice the strange fake gums he's got?

[Amarok]

 I'm simply stating some obvious truths and some personal opinions that you're too much of a crybaby to deal with.

You stated no truths but lots of opinions all of them worthy of scorn and I'm sorry if your descion to not bother address my points and going on some political tangent on some the thread (isn't about the politics of trans rights ) got me miffed  

I'm sorry if you're just too stupid to understand that in the whole great, big, wide world there are a lot of people who just really don't buy your personal brand of bullshit, but that's really your problem, not mine.

I'm sorry if you too stupid too actually bring valid point up and understand this thread wasn't political or trans rights advocacy 

Only to a buffoon. Special rights and privileges like transgenders wanting the right to use bathrooms based on how they feel inside while literally everyone else is regulated by anatomy is a transgender issue. 

What part of this thread  wasn't about trans rights didn't you get  and this argument fails because this statement isn't true both are clearly begin regulated by gender identity thus this is not a special right .

In case you forgot, your retarded rant started with the premise that there is no valid reason for an anti-transgender sentiment.

There isn't and you have failed to provide 1 good reason that isn't wrong or a reason free opinion 

The fact that you are not smart enough to see that very obvious connection illustrates your woeful ability to be a transgender advocate.

The fact  you can't see this wasn't about  transgender advocacy illustrates you woeful inability to talk about this subject  

Your acceptance of my position is not particularly necessary. I really could care less if you buy my personal brand of bullshit or not.

Good because it's a bad opinion 

That's the difference between you and I. I'm quite comfortable knowing that people disagree with me, while you clearly only want to hear things that fit into your political microcosm

Which is funny considering your the one who brought up politics my original l post wasn't political in terms of trans rights 

After all I'm not the one who started this conversation proclaiming to know all the answers and lost his shit the first time someone posted something I didn't like. That was you...

Yeah no were did I proclaim to know everything and I "lost my shit " at the sheer fact free nonsense  and falsehoods that were your responses.

Perhaps you should just start all your threads with a plea to only respond by sucking your political dick...

Again funny as this was NOT  a political thread (not about the politics of trans rights )

---

It's become fashionable among certain elements to have an almost militant Anti Trans attitude this manifests itself in a attempt to pathologize or deny the existence of trans people . The following is some of these attempts and why they fail .

I really would like too know what part of this statement makes this about the politics of trans rights or any way tries to makes this political outside the existence or attempts to pathologize trans people which is whole separate argument  to how society should treat them .

[Maketakunai]

If It's not political, and not about rights then your topic has no discernable meaning. It's nothing but a holier-than-thou rant. "Some people don't like transgenders, but you do. So, you're going to tell everyone what you think. The end."

Your OP didn't ask a question. In it you simply listed a bunch of alleged anti-trans question answered by you. In typical yappy puppy fashion you used oversimplified-to-the-point-of-being-nonsensical one line responses to your own statements. You didn't ask a question, you didn't posit a theory. You simple pretended that you know everything about why people don't accept transgender people.

The discussion is political whether you're smart enough to know it is or not. The discussion is about rights whether you're smart enough to know it or not. If you just don't want to have those discussions then there is no need for your bizarre rant in the first place. People can be free to love trans people or hate them based on their own moral compass and personal beliefs and we can all just stop bothering to talk about trans people... There doesn't actually seem to be a point to this thread other than you think something and everyone else is wrong.

But hey! You clearly know everything about people who are anti-trans. So, I reckon it's all your fault for not handling the problem. You think you know everything about it but haven't done a damn thing to relieve their non-political pain and suffering. Now that I think of it, you really are a piece of shit for not using your vast knowledge of anti-trans sentiment for the advancement of trans-kind!

[Amarok]

If It's not political, and not about rights then your topic has no discernable meaning.

Nope one can talk about trans outside of politics or civil rights and it can be meaningful the fact you only see it as politics is your problem 

It's nothing but a holier-than-thou rant.

Nope it was a critique of a specific line of reasoning and why it doesn't work

"Some people don't like transgenders, but you do. So, you're going to tell everyone what you think. The end."

Nope it was "here are bad arguments and here's why they are bad "

Your OP didn't ask a question.

Didn't need too 

 you simply listed a bunch of alleged anti-trans question answered by you.

Yup it was a  critique of some arguments or a line of reasoning 

In typical yappy puppy fashion you used oversimplified-to-the-point-of-being-nonsensical one line responses to your own statements.

Nope the arguments were spot on not over simplistic and they only required one line to fail  

You didn't ask a question,

Didn't need too 

you didn't posit a theory.

A theory of what ? and why would this require a theory ?

You simple pretended that you know everything about why people don't accept transgender people.

I never even discuss the why I talked about the arguments or at least one line of arguments again I made this pretty clear in my opening post .

The discussion is political whether you're smart enough to know it is or not.

Nope the idea of trans can be discussed outside of politics 

The discussion is about rights whether you're smart enough to know it or not.

Nope what I was discussing was ontological not prescriptive you can talk about the former without 

If you just don't want to have those discussions then there is no need for your bizarre rant in the first place.

Nope I can do so without talking about either and there is nothing bizarre about my post  

People can be free to love trans people or hate them based on their own moral compass and personal beliefs and we can all just stop bothering to talk about trans people...

Nope

There doesn't actually seem to be a point to this thread other than you think something and everyone else is wrong.

I stated point of the thread and it's not that 

But hey! You clearly know everything about people who are anti-trans.

Never claimed that in fact the opposite 

So, I reckon it's all your fault for not handling the problem.

Again never claimed that and I do help solve the problem 

You think you know everything about it but haven't done a damn thing to relieve their non-political pain and suffering.

Again never claimed that and i do just that you do so love to assume things about people 

Now that I think of it, you really are a piece of shit for not using your vast knowledge of anti-trans sentiment for the advancement of trans-kind!

Again never claimed that and I already do that and the only POS here pal is you as you have shown throughout this forum .