That Gay Thread

[The Architect Of Fate]

If you're going to insist that everything I say is a lie without providing any evidence, What's the point?

Excuses excuses 

[Huggy Bear]

Well, treating Buck Breaking as a systemic form of abuse in slavery days, and then quote mining the Ask a Historian Reddit page I used to debunk it and claiming it's actually affirming that it was a common enough practice that it had its own name is a pretty big whopper.

Also, I'm dying to see what your "true" version of why the LGBT rights movement is a thing actually is, Jez.

You didn't debunk a damn thing...

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/buck_breaking

[The Architect Of Fate]

He debunked everything 

[Silver]

Round and round......dizzying.

[Rev. Rye]

1) I can't help but notice that not only are literally all the uses cited in the quotations tab less than seven years old (my membership on this forum is older than the oldest use of the phrase cited), the definition itself says it's "From 21st Century," decades after every black person enslaved in the US died off.

2) More to the point, Jez:

@Huggy Bear

Let me ask you a question:

Why do you think the LGBTQ community and their advocates advocate for these things in the first place? What do you suppose their motives are?

[The Architect Of Fate]

1) I can't help but notice that not only are literally all the uses cited in the quotations tab less than seven years old (my membership on this forum is older than the oldest use of the phrase cited), the definition itself says it's "From 21st Century," decades after every black person enslaved in the US died off.

2) More to the point, Jez:

@Huggy Bear

Let me ask you a question:

Why do you think the LGBTQ community and their advocates advocate for these things in the first place? What do you suppose their motives are?

Classic Huggy trying to dodge onto a new subject

[LadyForCamus]

Are you going to answer my question or…?

If you're going to insist that everything I say is a lie without providing any evidence, What's the point?

Once again, show where I lied...

I never said the word “lie.”  Saying things that don’t happen to be true is not necessarily the same as lying, but this is just a pathetically obvious distraction tactic on your part. What happened? Did you get cold feet? I’ll give you one more chance to answer my question and then I’m done wasting my time on you.

[Huggy Bear]

1) I can't help but notice that not only are literally all the uses cited in the quotations tab less than seven years old (my membership on this forum is older than the oldest use of the phrase cited), the definition itself says it's "From 21st Century," decades after every black person enslaved in the US died off.

2) More to the point, Jez:

@Huggy Bear

Let me ask you a question:

Why do you think the LGBTQ community and their advocates advocate for these things in the first place? What do you suppose their motives are?

What are you talking about? Do you think there is a slave owner manual with the words buck breaking in it? Or do you think white people (the same ones that have to have a white savior in every movie about slavery) are telling what really happened during slavery? I wonder what the Nazis would say if the they got to explain what happened during the holocaust.

Black male slaves were known as "bucks", you do know they were treated as livestock right? No one willing just becomes a slave, they literally have to have thier spirit broken. Why are you being so obtuse? Acting like blck people just loved being slave so much, that white people didn't have to do anything to them... smh

[The Architect Of Fate]

And more of Huggy's babble

[Rev. Rye]

I'd think there'd be at least some mention of it in the many slave narratives to have been written, survived to the present day, and then digitised in a conveniently searchable database. And there are hundreds, if not over a thousand in that database alone. If you can find a reference among them that talks about it, and makes explicit that when they say "breaking," they mean anal rape, then and only then may you bring it up again.

In the meantime, Jez, you can do something that's less time-consuming than that little snipe hunt and just: