Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: December 10, 2024, 4:14 am

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Free Will: Fact or Fiction
#11
RE: Free Will: Fact or Fiction
I know it's become fashionable lately to say that we don't have free will, but I don't buy it. We appear to have free will, so I think the burden of proof is on those who say we don't. I would like to see an experiment proposed to show that our will is not free.
[Image: generic_sig.jpg]
Reply
#12
RE: Free Will: Fact or Fiction
Um...no. Just because something appears to be so, that does not shift the burden of proof.

And we could do an experiment to show that our will is not free, however, the one I'm thinking of would require smashing someone's frontal lobe.
Even if the open windows of science at first make us shiver after the cozy indoor warmth of traditional humanizing myths, in the end the fresh air brings vigor, and the great spaces have a splendor of their own - Bertrand Russell
Reply
#13
RE: Free Will: Fact or Fiction
Sure, I think I have freewill. I do not, however, believe my freewill is a gracious gift bestowed upon me by a deity.
42

Reply
#14
RE: Free Will: Fact or Fiction
Determinism and fatalism are concepts that I am not willing to accept for two reasons; a support of human free will and a more meta issue with the arguments themselves.
In support of free will, given the massive amounts of freedom of choice we have (now more than ever, it seems), the different choices made by identically determined individuals, the actual rational contemplation of which we are possessed and so on, I find determinism and fatalism at once unpalatable and in need of much greater consideration before it becomes anything near acceptable.
Secondly, the argument for determinism is piss-weak, we act differently to natural phenomena and we are by no means set into a series of unchangable events. The dialectic issue that I take with this is that the fundamental and quintessential defence of it is 'but you're determined to say that' and no argument to the contrary seems to penetrate the infernally thick skull of a determinist, especially *shudders* a Nietzschean. Just as a christian and marxist won't concede their fundamental assertion, it is simply bad disputational etiquette.
Religion is an attempt to answer the philosophical questions of the unphilosophical man.
Reply
#15
RE: Free Will: Fact or Fiction
It's demonstrable that some of our actions are purely chemical/neurological (e.g. fits of uncontrollable rage/falling in love) also that interfering with brain functions can drastically alter 'personality' (e.g. a blow to the head/electric shock therapy). These are strong arguments against the concept of free will as it means that behaviour can be predicted. We realise this, instinctively & regularly, when we make predictions on how people will react based on prior experience of their actions/reactions (e.g. 'knowing' your friends/business stakeholder analyses).

On the other hand, it's demonstrable that people can behave in ways inconsistent with chemical/neurological expectations (e.g. controlling their emotions) also that people have 'recovered' from altered brain functions (e.g. reasserting personality). These are strong arguments in favour of free will because it means that behaviour runs contrary to predictions. We realise this, less commonly than predictability, when our expectations of behaviour are not met (e.g. people 'not being themselves').

I feel that our current understanding of biology & neurochemistry is insufficient to come to any conclusions about behavioural drivers but it's almost definitely true that it's not as simple as free will vs determinism; I think it likely that those terms are drastic oversimplifications of incredibly complex social, psychological & neurological mechanisms, the type of which may be theoretically predictable but probably contain too many variables to be practically so.

In reality, we observe that people are more predictable than not.
Sum ergo sum
Reply
#16
RE: Free Will: Fact or Fiction
(September 25, 2012 at 3:20 pm)Tino Wrote: I know it's become fashionable lately to say that we don't have free will, but I don't buy it. We appear to have free will, so I think the burden of proof is on those who say we don't. I would like to see an experiment proposed to show that our will is not free.

Scientific date regarding something as vague as free will is hard to do.

However, as I was saying, chemical reactions in our brain control us and from what I've heard, scientists have actually done brain scans on people, observing the chemical reaction that leads them to make a choice before the choice is actually made. I still think we're slaves to those chemical reactions in our brain, if not for our entire consciousness being those chemical reactions in the first place.
I live on facebook. Come see me there. http://www.facebook.com/tara.rizzatto

"If you cling to something as the absolute truth and you are caught in it, when the truth comes in person to knock on your door you will refuse to let it in." ~ Siddhartha Gautama
Reply
#17
RE: Free Will: Fact or Fiction
Hmmm...that's a tough one. I've heard of a study where a part of the brain corresponding to a certain action lit up noticibly before the action took place, but what about if the environment changed between the light up and the action? Would it be impossible to change your mind? I don't think it would. I know that hormones and other impulses have some effect on you, and that you are influenced by past experiences, but I think that there is enough you can control for there to be free will. For example, you can choose to resist your biological instincts. If we were complete slaves to them we would always be acting on them. This, however, brings up an interesting question: How complex must an organism be before it has free will? (For instance do any animals have free will, and if so what is the least complex one that does)
John Adams Wrote:The Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion.
Reply
#18
RE: Free Will: Fact or Fiction
Here's a copy/paste of what I wrote on another post in this forum:
(August 18, 2012 at 5:20 pm)pocaracas Wrote: I think I see where you're getting.... either it's all pre-destined physics, or... god gave us free will.

My take is: all pre-destined physics. But the physics involved is soooo complex, that you can see it as free will..... my guess is that you end up making the decision you have to make from all the physical processes that occur in your brain. And you make the decision that your brain makes (duh!)

The decision making process is entirely based on a) genetics and b) previous experience/knowledge.
Genetics can't be tweaked in any way... If you're born a fool you're a fool forever! These are the tools Nature gives you to work with.
Experience is in constant change, so, from our point of view, it's completely .... random?...naaahhhh.... unpredictable.... and we like to call it "conscious". Tongue
Reply
#19
RE: Free Will: Fact or Fiction
I don't see that anyone really has free will. This seems to be more of an illusion than reality.

Did you choose your parents or what they would teach you? Did you choose the time period and culture that you would be born in? Did you choose the opportunities that would be made available to you in life? Did you choose your personality or preferences?

On top of all that, you at all times choose what you most desire, our decisions are chained/limited by what our greatest desire is (you can have conflicting ones).....but we can't even choose our desires.

I believe only God can change your desire. I believe that by nature people do not find God appealing.

It's only by God's intervening that anyone would see a relationship with Him as desirable or even plausible.

I believe that (for real Christians) God changes the desires of your heart and allows you to see Him as He is....glorious.

These are my opinions as a Reformed Christian. I am not stating them as fact so please no "prove it" statements. I'm simply wanting to throw in as it were.
Reply
#20
RE: Free Will: Fact or Fiction
(September 25, 2012 at 5:58 pm)Reasonable_Jeff Wrote: I don't see that anyone really has free will. This seems to be more of an illusion than reality.

Did you choose your parents or what they would teach you? Did you choose the time period and culture that you would be born in? Did you choose the opportunities that would be made available to you in life? Did you choose your personality or preferences?

On top of all that, you at all times choose what you most desire, our decisions are chained/limited by what our greatest desire is (you can have conflicting ones).....but we can't even choose our desires.

I believe only God can change your desire. I believe that by nature people do not find God appealing.

It's only by God's intervening that anyone would see a relationship with Him as desirable or even plausible.

I believe that (for real Christians) God changes the desires of your heart and allows you to see Him as He is....glorious.

These are my opinions as a Reformed Christian. I am not stating them as fact so please no "prove it" statements. I'm simply wanting to throw in as it were.

So what you're saying is that god claimed we had free will, but not only do we not, but god sometimes influences our decisions subconciously? Then how can anyone go to heaven or hell?
John Adams Wrote:The Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion.
Reply



Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Why do people believe that Beowulf is fiction? I_am_not_mafia 59 15257 June 6, 2018 at 6:02 am
Last Post: Gawdzilla Sama
  Explaining the fact that we exist OttoVonKerpen 84 13705 November 5, 2016 at 11:18 pm
Last Post: TheoneandonlytrueGod
  When it becomes a fact? _Velvet_ 14 3138 October 10, 2016 at 3:59 pm
Last Post: The Grand Nudger
  Fact, every single german nazi was a christian Deepthunk 249 68502 August 16, 2016 at 8:33 pm
Last Post: Anomalocaris
  Best use of hymns and bible quotes in fiction? Lemonvariable72 14 3830 November 21, 2015 at 6:14 am
Last Post: pgrimes15
  Jerry Coyne's new book: Faith Versus Fact Mudhammam 17 6471 August 13, 2015 at 12:22 am
Last Post: smsavage32
  My very first fiction novel officially debuts tomorrow! Mudhammam 18 6891 January 8, 2015 at 2:01 am
Last Post: bennyboy
  The more troubling fact is not that this may be genuine, but that it's hard to doubt Mudhammam 16 5488 August 13, 2014 at 1:50 pm
Last Post: Lucanus
  36 Arguments for the existence of god: a work of fiction AtheistChurch 1 2027 March 9, 2010 at 8:25 pm
Last Post: fr0d0



Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)