Yes, it is presumptuous, but it is valid on any theist who comes to AF.org to "tell those pesky atheists how their faith works"...
You may keep trying your approach, of course, but bear in mind that, as soon as you say "if god exists", they win the argument, because they know their god, and you know your version of their god, which is seldom their god, and they'll always claim strawman.
You claim you deconverted, at some point... did it start with the realization that god maybe dead? Or did it start a bit before?
You may keep trying your approach, of course, but bear in mind that, as soon as you say "if god exists", they win the argument, because they know their god, and you know your version of their god, which is seldom their god, and they'll always claim strawman.
You claim you deconverted, at some point... did it start with the realization that god maybe dead? Or did it start a bit before?