Can you make a God claim?

[robvalue]

For example, claiming there is an omniscient God who gives us free will is an inconsistent claim (as I think I demonstrated in another thread). So it's pointless to put forward because it cannot be true, unless you are to demonstrate that contradictions can exist and logic doesn't apply, or something.

---

It's also untestable, if I give no way in which this God can be distinguished from nothing.

Hehe yeah. I dunno, might make someone think about what it is they "believe" and why.

---

There has been more productive discussion on this thread than I've seen on many others, I've seen much more thoughtful comments. We may never get to what I asked for, but I feel some people have stopped to think a little bit which is great.

---

I take the point alpha male, I could have done better in my OP. The consistency part was perhaps a bit overdone, it was an attempt to stop absurd claims that make utterly no sense, or which make wild unsubstantiated assumptions. Let's focus on a testable claim. And as cat sniper pointed out, this means it must be falsifiable. Or else it's just a proclamation of truth, or presentation of the unknowable.