(February 19, 2015 at 11:09 am)FatAndFaithless Wrote: I'd actually be willing to agree that a study like that is likely to exist (though in a much more coherent and less pulled-out-his-ass form, certainly not just 'dropping kids on a desert island'), but that just illustrates the process through which religions are started. Creating stories to explain unknown events and attributing them to higher beings is the modus operandi for fledgling religions. I don't know how YGninja thinks the Egyptian or Greek or Hindu pantheons started, but it's very much like people experiencing natural phenomena and, lacking sufficient explanation with the information we have nowadays, creating their 'best guess' usually illustrated through stories and myths.
YGninja's own points undercut his conclusions from the very start.
(Not even mentioning the tribes in South America that have no God concept at all)
Oh, I don't doubt that there's some study that he is misrepresenting. I just want to see it for myself. Judging by his misguided and dishonest argument regarding the 1st Amendment, I would require independent corroboration if he told me the sky appeared blue on a cloudless day. Just another believer willing to lie for Jesus.