Muhammad the Greatest: A Comparative Study

[Al-Fatihah]

Sure Al. Your prophet is an insider in childishness right?

You are a fundamentalist. It's therefore necessary to ridiculize your ideas, because they are dangerous. And besides, allah is imiginary anyway. So let's call stupidity by it's name; Muhammed.

Response: In other words, since one can't refute the challenge of the Qur'an because it clearly proves that the Qur'an is the true word of Allah, they troll the thread and cry in the process. How sad it is.

[Darkstar]

What if Mo was an alien using advanced technology to trick people? Or maybe he was Satan of the Christian religion? Or maybe he was time traveller from the future?

You know, someone here (Drich, maybe?) suggested that Allah might be Satan, because Lucifer means light bringer, and Allah is supposedly seen as a light.

New idea: Al-Fatihah needs to disprove Jesus first.
Also, what does it mean to be 'against' the wants and beliefs of the people. I'm sure that everyday Germans didn't burn Jews for a pastime in the 40's, but Hitler still took over, didn't he?

[Cato]

You guys still playing chess with this pigeon?

More like watching him turn circles in a Skinner box without the reinforcement of food.

[Darkstar]

Response: In other words, since one can't refute the challenge of the Qur'an because it clearly proves that the Qur'an is the true word of Allah, they troll the thread and cry in the process. How sad it is.

It doesn't prove anything other than how guillible the people back then were.

[Al-Fatihah]

And I thought Christians were stubborn. Have you ever thought the REASON why he was able to 'conquer' a nation was because he was made up precisely for that purpose, a Muslim Hercules or Achilles, and people just believed whatever they were told about him?
As for your Rebuttals there are repetitive, please think of something original.
If you Mohammed cam today to me with his massage, I would point him to the nearest mental heath clinic.

Response: The better question is, don't you realize that every time you dodge the challenge it only suports and confirms your denial to the fact that the challenge proves that you are wrong and the Qur'an is true? If the challenge was invalid, you can easily prove it by answering it. But instead, you duck and hide in the corner. Thus exposing the fact that the challenge proves that the Qur'an is the true word of Allah. Back in the corner you go.

[Faith No More]

Claiming that the Qur'an must either be duplicatable or the inspired word of god is a false dilemma.

[Cyberman]

Response: Way to shift the burden of proof and pretend as if you didn't.

Ask for proof of something.

Proof that can be tested and verified is presented

Start to complain because you don't like the idea that by testing the evidence as required, it debunks your claim

Use a strawman that the burden of proof has been shifted

Way to go

Gruntfuttock: Even in this peculiar procedure, you haven't got any further than step one.

[Dee Dee Ramone]

Sure Al. Your prophet is an insider in childishness right?

You are a fundamentalist. It's therefore necessary to ridiculize your ideas, because they are dangerous. And besides, allah is imiginary anyway. So let's call stupidity by it's name; Muhammed.

Response: In other words, since one can't refute the challenge of the Qur'an because it clearly proves that the Qur'an is the true word of Allah, they troll the thread and cry in the process. How sad it is.

You are an insult to my intelligence, keep begging the question Al.

[pocaracas]

Whenever I see a wall of text a few pages down the thread, I google a passage:
https://www.google.com/search?num=100&hl...5hdYJO_ZQs

You've been busy, spreading the same piece of text everywhere and sticking to the same "I'm right, you can't prove me wrong, so I'm definitely right" speech.

For this sort of claims, there is the Flying Spaghetti Monster.
The religion that worships the FSM is called pastafarianism.
This is the symbol of this most mightiest of mightiests, most holiest of holies:


Pastafarianism is growing steadily and has various churches around the world.

As it says in the image above, if you can prove that your religion is right, these guys will stop believing in the FSM.
So, please do so!

Otherwise, your claim that "the qur'an is the true word of Allah" has an equal footing as the pastafarianists' claim that the FSM is "up there".

[Faith No More]

What is a gruntfuttock?