Indisputable proof for a God

[Captain Scarlet]

http://deoband.org/2010/03/aqida/allah-a...a-creator/

Please respond. Thanks.

1 Its fallacious. Begs the question. Commits compositional errors and has at least 2 questionable premises.

2 There are better natural explanations which can be tested for to demo how and why hands move.

3 can anyone take it seriously. You cannot argue to a god from this. The conclusion might as well be therefore hand moving invisi-fairies exist.

[ozy123]

http://deoband.org/2010/03/aqida/allah-a...a-creator/

Please respond. Thanks.

1 Its fallacious. Begs the question. Commits compositional errors and has at least 2 questionable premises.

2 There are better natural explanations which can be tested for to demo how and why hands move.

3 can anyone take it seriously. You cannot argue to a god from this. The conclusion might as well be therefore hand moving invisi-fairies exist.

thanks for your response.

There is a debate taking place at the sunni muslim forum. Obviously you do not have to come and join in if your not that way inclined but the author of the article is defending and clarifying his article there - http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/showthre...suf-Mullan

[Minimalist]

Have you read the Qur'an or the other sacred texts?

Yes.

They are the preposterous ramblings of primitive men.


What else have you got?