Grand Nudger:
I told this is (was) the propaganda of the catholic church. Since Jesus was the only savior, Mohammad had to be a fake prophet, a warlord or even the Anti-Christ. Atheists inherited this view from the Church. But I’ve read a book or two on the life of Mohammad. Not only he (the first caliph) was not a warlord, but his son in law (Ali) was murdered by the founder of the Umayyad Caliphate (Mu’awiyah) and this was the guy who turned religion into a circus that happened mainly in houses of worship with a limited group of people who had “the key” to Islamic teachings and the rest following them like a flock.
I’m talking as a spiritual person here. This is a type of understanding in which a deity (separate from us – perhaps even living on mount Olympus) is watching us from above (to punish us basically) and this whole world with all the hardship people are enduring is some sort of a test. At the end of the test it’s either Hades or it’s younger prostitutes in some other room of heaven.
So no. This is not really me. In me there is this inner-phenomenon which is present in all human beings (tall – short, Black – white, Man – Woman – Transgender …). And I am doing some disciplined studies paired with a number of spiritual practices (none of which are performative, In fact no one even knows about my spiritual practices). All of this with the aim of increasing my understanding of this inner phenomenon.
Scriptures, prophets, writers and spiritual are but tools in this endeavor. And none of them has any monopoly on that. Almost all religious thinkers including this Y.N. Ozturk have this idea that their path (if not the only one) is actually the best spiritual path anyone can follow. In the 21st century there is no greater nonsense + we are immortal beings (souls). So in terms of spirituality, if one decides to spend one or even 7 lifetimes being the most radical / materialistic type of atheist, the Universe has 0 problem with that and so do I.
/So don’t fall by this propaganda. You seem like a person who has some spare time. Why don’t you check some local library to see if you can borrow something about the life of the prophet of Islam?
- So do I. But following an old school traditional type of religion is different with being interested in the deeper messages that are present in all of these religions. It’s not that I have a problem with the more traditional types of believers either. But if I discuss stuff with them (and I rarely do that because the politicized versions of these religions are basically a form of Bolshevism or the neo-Nazi ideology or todays hardliner Nigel Farage types of fascists.) but if I do, I will point the the lacking points of their spiritual approaches too.
Ex: why on earth does one read a scripture just for gaining points from the Deity?
- I think these people are missing the whole point. You need to read and understand that stuff. Than you even decide whether you believe that stuff or not. I don’t see the point of reciting stuff in Latin, Hebrew or ancient Arabic without even understanding stuff.
Self-correction: There are people seeking deeper meaning in these texts. They will go as far as learning Aramaic to study the Bible. That’s not what I am talking about here. The first task of a typical Christian should be to try to read at least some chapters of the old and New Testament.
- You know I totally respect this approach. I have 0 problem with it because what you say is true. Today I am glad that Pope Leo survived his lung cancer. And I like seeing him in the news talking about facing the sexual abuse issues and calling for an end to the war in Ukraine. But what did I just say? – It’s because of his church that some 90% of the Western world still perceives Mohammad as a blood thirsty barbarian who fooled everyone including himself.
I would surely lose it if I focused on these issues all the time. So this thread is just what it is. If you read it, you can just forget about it. The only part that matters to me is the spiritual teaching part. I think you must have understood this until now.
Quote:“Mohamed -was- warlord. He did not detest violence. He used the pretense of defense like any of our favorite American presidents have over the course of our lives. You may think it’s better if people didn’t believe mo was who he was, didn’t do what he did. That the whole enterprise didn’t immediately fall to the squabbling of entitled princes looking to carve up his ill gotten gains….but that’s what happened.”
I told this is (was) the propaganda of the catholic church. Since Jesus was the only savior, Mohammad had to be a fake prophet, a warlord or even the Anti-Christ. Atheists inherited this view from the Church. But I’ve read a book or two on the life of Mohammad. Not only he (the first caliph) was not a warlord, but his son in law (Ali) was murdered by the founder of the Umayyad Caliphate (Mu’awiyah) and this was the guy who turned religion into a circus that happened mainly in houses of worship with a limited group of people who had “the key” to Islamic teachings and the rest following them like a flock.
I’m talking as a spiritual person here. This is a type of understanding in which a deity (separate from us – perhaps even living on mount Olympus) is watching us from above (to punish us basically) and this whole world with all the hardship people are enduring is some sort of a test. At the end of the test it’s either Hades or it’s younger prostitutes in some other room of heaven.

So no. This is not really me. In me there is this inner-phenomenon which is present in all human beings (tall – short, Black – white, Man – Woman – Transgender …). And I am doing some disciplined studies paired with a number of spiritual practices (none of which are performative, In fact no one even knows about my spiritual practices). All of this with the aim of increasing my understanding of this inner phenomenon.
Scriptures, prophets, writers and spiritual are but tools in this endeavor. And none of them has any monopoly on that. Almost all religious thinkers including this Y.N. Ozturk have this idea that their path (if not the only one) is actually the best spiritual path anyone can follow. In the 21st century there is no greater nonsense + we are immortal beings (souls). So in terms of spirituality, if one decides to spend one or even 7 lifetimes being the most radical / materialistic type of atheist, the Universe has 0 problem with that and so do I.
/So don’t fall by this propaganda. You seem like a person who has some spare time. Why don’t you check some local library to see if you can borrow something about the life of the prophet of Islam?
Quote:“I “think evil” of the abrahamics because those religions put in the work. The record of history, often enough in their own words…because why would they know better or think any different…stands as their accuser.”
- So do I. But following an old school traditional type of religion is different with being interested in the deeper messages that are present in all of these religions. It’s not that I have a problem with the more traditional types of believers either. But if I discuss stuff with them (and I rarely do that because the politicized versions of these religions are basically a form of Bolshevism or the neo-Nazi ideology or todays hardliner Nigel Farage types of fascists.) but if I do, I will point the the lacking points of their spiritual approaches too.
Ex: why on earth does one read a scripture just for gaining points from the Deity?
- I think these people are missing the whole point. You need to read and understand that stuff. Than you even decide whether you believe that stuff or not. I don’t see the point of reciting stuff in Latin, Hebrew or ancient Arabic without even understanding stuff.
Self-correction: There are people seeking deeper meaning in these texts. They will go as far as learning Aramaic to study the Bible. That’s not what I am talking about here. The first task of a typical Christian should be to try to read at least some chapters of the old and New Testament.
Quote:“It isn’t because I dont know enough about abrahamic religion that I think it’s a raging garbage fire…it’s because I’ve spent quite a bit of time learning about abrahamic religion that I think it’s a raging garbage fire. You may think that new age babble or contemporary revisionism can save it….but that very impulse of yours gives up the game entirely. You also recognize that it’s bullshit. You’re looking to save it…by replacing it….with something else. Good luck, I hope you don’t get killed for it.”
- You know I totally respect this approach. I have 0 problem with it because what you say is true. Today I am glad that Pope Leo survived his lung cancer. And I like seeing him in the news talking about facing the sexual abuse issues and calling for an end to the war in Ukraine. But what did I just say? – It’s because of his church that some 90% of the Western world still perceives Mohammad as a blood thirsty barbarian who fooled everyone including himself.
I would surely lose it if I focused on these issues all the time. So this thread is just what it is. If you read it, you can just forget about it. The only part that matters to me is the spiritual teaching part. I think you must have understood this until now.
![[Image: 7151bc275de2d3d422106a4008215efe.jpg]](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/71/51/bc/7151bc275de2d3d422106a4008215efe.jpg)


