Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: November 15, 2026, 8:07 pm

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Historian explains why Jesus ''mythers'' aren't taken seriously by most Historians
#41
RE: Historian explains why Jesus ''mythers'' aren't taken seriously by most Historians
(June 5, 2015 at 3:43 pm)TheMessiah Wrote:
(June 5, 2015 at 3:41 pm)Simon Moon Wrote: I wonder what Tim O'Neil has to say about this?


The 'Oxford Classical Dictionary', one of the foremost authorities on the Greco-Roman world, does not have an entry for Jeshua Ben Yusef?


http://debunkingchristianity.blogspot.co...alify.html


"The 3rd. ed. continues the title:  The Oxford Classical Dictionary: The Ultimate Reference Work on the Classical World includes more than 6,200 entries, but again fails to provided any entry on Jesus nor has it any use for the New Testament as a historical record.  Although the entry on Josephus is expanded in the newer editions, the Dictionary dismisses the Testimonium Flavianum account on Jesus as reliable history in just one sentence: “The famous testimonium to Jesus is partly or even wholly an interpolation.” (p. 798)

Likewise, there are no entries on Gospels, New Testament, nor does the Dictionary list a single reference  to any Biblical book under its section: Abbreviations Used in the Present Work   A. General  B. Authors and Books in its 75 pages."


I don't believe Oxford are in the 'fringe', are they?  

Did you read the post or not? I'll take the relevant information, but this was clearly addressed.

There are two major historical references to Jesus from the greco-Roman world.


Quote:Many Christian apologists vastly overstate the number of ancient non-Christian writers who attest to the existence of Jesus.  This is partly because they are not simply showing that a mere Jewish preacher existed, but are arguing for the existence of the "Jesus Christ" of Christian doctrine: a supposedly supernatural figure who allegedly performed amazing public miracles in front of audiences of thousands of witnesses.  It could certainly be argued that such a wondrous figure would have been noticed outside of Galilee and Judea and so should have been widely noted as well.  So Christian apologists often cite a long list of writers who mention Jesus, usually including Josephus, Pliny the Younger, Tacitus, Suetonius, Lucian, Thallus and several others.  But of these only Tacitus and Josephus actually mention Jesus as a historical person - the others are all simply references to early Christianity, some of which mention the "Christ" that was the focus of its worship.

If we are simply noting the existence of Jesus as a human Jewish preacher, we are not required to produce more mentions of him than we would expect of comparable figures.  And what we find is that we have about as much evidence for his existence (outside any Christian writings) as we have for other Jewish preachers, prophets and Messianic claimants of the time.  The two non-Christian writers who mention him as a historical person are Josephus and Tacitus.

Josephus

The Jewish priestly aristocrat Joseph ben Matityahu, who took the Roman name Flavius Josephus, is our main source of information about Jewish affairs in this period and is usually the only writer of the time who makes any mention of Jewish preachers, prophets and Messianic claimants of the First Century.  Not surprisingly, he mentions Jesus twice: firstly in some detail in Antiquities of the Jews XVIII.3.4 and again more briefly when mentioning the execution of Jesus' brother James in Antiquities XX.9.1.  The first reference is problematic, however, as it contains elements which Josephus cannot have written and which seem to have been added later by a Christian interpolator.  Here is the text, with the likely interpolations in bold:

"Now there was about this time Jesus, a wise man, if it be lawful to call
him a man; for he was a doer of paradoxical deeds, a teacher of such men
as receive the truth with pleasure. He drew over to him both many of the
Jews and many of the Gentiles. He was [the] Christ And when Pilate at the suggestion of the principal men amongst us, had condemned him to the cross,
those that loved him at the first did not forsake him; for he appeared
to them alive again the third day; as the divine prophets had foretold
these and ten thousand other wonderful things concerning him. And the
tribe of Christians, so named from him, are not extinct at this day."

There has been a long debate about what parts of this reference to Jesus are authentic to Josephus or even if the whole passage is a wholesale interpolation.  Proponents of the Jesus Myth hypothesis, naturally, opt for the idea that it is not authentic in any way, but there are strong indications that, apart from the obvious additions shown in bold above, Josephus did mention Jesus at this point in his text.

To begin with, several elements in the passage are distinctively Josephean in their style and phrasing.  "Now (there was) about this time ..." is used by Josephus as a way of introducing a new topic hundreds of times in his work.  There are no early Christian parallels that refer to Jesus merely as "a wise man", but this is a term used by Josephus several times, eg about Solomon and Daniel.  Christian writers placed a lot of emphasis on Jesus' miracles, but here the passage uses a fairly neutral term παραδόξων ἔργων - "paradoxa erga" or "paradoxical deeds".  Josephus does use this phrase elsewhere about the miracles of Elisha, but the term can also mean "deeds that are difficult to interpret" and even has overtones of cautious scepticism.  Finally, the use of the word φῦλον ("phylon" - "race, tribe") is not used by Christians about themselves in any works of the time, but is used by Josephus elsewhere about sects, nations or other distinct groups.  Additionally, with the sole exception of Χριστιανῶν ("Christianon" - "Christians") every single word in the passage can be found elsewhere in Josephus' writings.

The weight of the evidence of the vocabulary and style of the passage is heavily towards its partial authenticity.  Not only does it contain distinctive phrases of Josephus that he used in similar contexts elsewhere, but these are also phrases not found in early Christian texts.  And it is significantly free of terms and phrases from the gospels, which we'd expect to find if it was created wholesale by a Christian writer.  So either a very clever Christian interpolator somehow managed to immerse himself in Josephus' phrasing and language, without modern concordances and dictionaries and create a passage containing distinctively Josephean phraseology, or what we have here is a genuinely Josephean passage that has simply been added to rather clumsily.

As a result of this and other evidence (eg the Arabic and Syriac paraphrases of this passage which seem to come from a version before the clumsy additions by the interpolator) the consensus amongst scholars of all backgrounds is that the passage is partially genuine, simply added in a few obvious places.  Louis H. Feldman's Josephus and Modern Scholarship (1984) surveys scholarship on the question from 1937 to 1980 and finds of 52 scholars on the subject, 39 considered the passage to be partially authentic.  

Peter Kirby has done a survey of the literature since and found that this trend has increased in recent years.  He concludes "In my own reading of thirteen books since 1980 that touch upon the passage, ten out of thirteen argue the (Antiquities of the Jews XVIII.3.4 passage) to be partly genuine, while the other three maintain it to be entirely spurious. Coincidentally, the same three books also argue that Jesus did not exist."  


The other mention of Jesus in Josephus, Antiquities XX.9.1, is much more straightforward, but much more of a problem for Jesus Mythicists.  In it Josephus recounts a major political event that happened when he was a young man.  This would have been a significant and memorable event for him, since he was only 25 at the time and it caused upheaval in his own social and political class, the priestly families of Jerusalem that included his own.

In 62 AD the Roman procurator of Judea, Porcius Festus, died while in office and his replacement, Lucceius Albinus, was still on his way to Judea from Rome.  This left the High Priest, Hanan ben Hanan (usually called Ananus), with a freer reign than usual. Ananus executed some Jews without Roman permission and, when this was brought to the attention of the Romans, Ananus was deposed.  This deposition would have been memorable for the young Josephus, who had just returned from an embassy to Rome on the behalf of the Jerusalem priests.  But what makes this passage relevant is what Josephus mentions, in passing, as the cause of the political upheaval:

Festus was now dead, and Albinus was but upon the road; so (the High Priest) assembled the Sanhedrin of judges, and brought before them the brother of Jesus, who was called Messiah, whose name was James, and some others; and when he had formed an accusation against them as breakers of the law, he delivered them to be stoned.

This mention is peripheral to the story Josephus is telling, but since we know from Christian sources that Jesus' brother James led the Jesus sect in Jerusalem in this period and we have a separate, non-dependent, Christian account of James' execution by the Jerusalem priesthood, it is fairly clear which "Jesus who was called Messiah" Josephus is referring to here.

Almost without exception, modern scholars consider this passage genuine and an undisputed reference to Jesus as a historical figure by someone who was a contemporary of his brother and who knew of the execution of that brother first hand.  This rather unequivocal reference to a historical Jesus leaves Jesus Mythicists with a thorny problem, which they generally try to solve one of two ways:

(i) "The words "who was called Messiah" are a later Christian interpolation" -

Since it is wholly unlikely that a Christian interpolator invented the whole story of the deposition of the High Priest just to slip in this passing reference to Jesus, Mythicists try to argue that the key words which identify which Jesus is being spoken of are interpolated.  Unfortunately this argument does not work.  This is because the passage is discussed no less than three times in mid-Third Century works by the Christian apologist Origen and he directly quotes the relevant section with the words "Jesus who was called the Messiah" all three times: in Contra Celsum I.4, in Contra Celsum II:13 and in Commentarium in evangelium Matthaei X.17.  Each time he uses precisely the phrase we find in Josephus: αδελφος Ιησου του λεγομενου Χριστου ("the brother of that Jesus who was called Messiah").  This is significant because Origen was writing a whole generation before Christianity was in any kind of position to be tampering with texts of Josephus.  If this phrase was in the passage in Origen's time, then it was clearly original to Josephus.

The name 'Yeshua' is just a translation of Jesus.



Did you read my post?

One of the foremost authorities on the Greco-Roman world, The Oxford Classical Dictionary, has no entry for Jesus, nor to they reference any book of the NT as a historical source. 

I've read Tim O'Neil before. He makes a strong case.

All I posted is a reputable historical source that does not consider the case for a historical Jesus to have an entry for him in a scholarly historical reference book. 

I believe you reversed your last statement. Jesus is the translation of Yeshua.

You'd believe if you just opened your heart" is a terrible argument for religion. It's basically saying, "If you bias yourself enough, you can convince yourself that this is true." If religion were true, people wouldn't need faith to believe it -- it would be supported by good evidence.
Reply
#42
RE: Historian explains why Jesus ''mythers'' aren't taken seriously by most Historians
(June 5, 2015 at 3:54 pm)Simon Moon Wrote:
(June 5, 2015 at 3:43 pm)TheMessiah Wrote: Did you read the post or not? I'll take the relevant information, but this was clearly addressed.

There are two major historical references to Jesus from the greco-Roman world.



The name 'Yeshua' is just a translation of Jesus.



Did you read my post?

One of the foremost authorities on the Greco-Roman world, The Oxford Classical Dictionary, has no entry for Jesus, nor to they reference any book of the NT as a historical source. 

I've read Tim O'Neil before. He makes a strong case.

All I posted is a reputable historical source that does not consider the case for a historical Jesus to have an entry for him in a scholarly historical reference book. 

I believe you reversed your last statement. Jesus is the translation of Yeshua.

I read your post - I then highlighted a specific part of the one I quoted.

What Christians claim Jesus is isn't what Historians claim he is - the historical Jesus, and the version of Jesus that Tim (and many other Historians) refer to is simply a human Jewish preacher who had a grassroots following and died a disgraceful death. And despite his relative insignificance, we have at-east 2 historical references to him/that figure. The ones I cited, are of two of the most reputable scholars of the time.

The reality is that he doesn't really deserve a place on the list, because historically, he isn't significant. The fame surrounding Jesus is based on the concept of Christ, as a saviour.
Reply
#43
RE: Historian explains why Jesus ''mythers'' aren't taken seriously by most Historians
So... Jesus is only 99% mythical then. That doesn't exactly make the mythicist possession mental in my opinion. I don't see what difference it makes about that 1% of banal factoids. Why is this such a big deal I wonder? When you have that little information about someone, saying it's "based on" them really doesn't mean much at all. His life story is mythical. (Or in scepto speak, we have no good reason to think his life story is anything other than almost entirely mythical. Angels and shit are a bit of a giveaway.)

The Jesus written about in the bible is not a real person. He is a ridiculous story told about someone who quite possibly existed, or quite possibly more than one person shoved together.
Feel free to send me a private message.
Please visit my website here! It's got lots of information about atheism/theism and support for new atheists.

Index of useful threads and discussions
Index of my best videos
Quickstart guide to the forum
Reply
#44
RE: Historian explains why Jesus ''mythers'' aren't taken seriously by most Historians
FFS - hide tags, people!
At the age of five, Skagra decided emphatically that God did not exist.  This revelation tends to make most people in the universe who have it react in one of two ways - with relief or with despair.  Only Skagra responded to it by thinking, 'Wait a second.  That means there's a situation vacant.'
Reply
#45
RE: Historian explains why Jesus ''mythers'' aren't taken seriously by most Historians
(June 5, 2015 at 4:02 pm)robvalue Wrote: So... Jesus is only 99% mythical then. I don't see what difference it makes about that 1% of banal factoids. Why is this such a big deal I wonder? When you have that little information about someone, saying it's "based on" them really doesn't mean much at all.

I don't know what you mean by 99% mythical. No serious Historian, nor me ever proposed that Jesus was a magical figure - I'm not going to entertain absurdity.

But was he a figure who had a grassroots movement, tried to reform the Jewish faith and got killed for it? Most likely. His followers had to reconcile his embarrassing death and the Jewish prophecy.

The evidence for his existence is actually better attested to than some other historical figures - I mean, we all know how illogical Christians are, but sometimes I wonder whether there is an ideological desire to undermine the existence of Jesus.
Reply
#46
RE: Historian explains why Jesus ''mythers'' aren't taken seriously by most Historians
Err... you don't know what I mean? I mean 99% made up. I'm not trying to undermine anything. I don't care if he was real or not, he's just some asswipe.

Did I say you said that? You seem a bit defensive.

I didn't say I was a mythicist, by the way.

If other historical figures are less well documented then I feel very sorry for them Tongue It's flattery to call the gospels "documented" I think.
Feel free to send me a private message.
Please visit my website here! It's got lots of information about atheism/theism and support for new atheists.

Index of useful threads and discussions
Index of my best videos
Quickstart guide to the forum
Reply
#47
RE: Historian explains why Jesus ''mythers'' aren't taken seriously by most Historians
(June 5, 2015 at 4:06 pm)robvalue Wrote: Err... you don't know what I mean? I mean 99% made up. I'm not trying to undermine anything. I don't care if he was real or not, he's just some asswipe.

I didn't say I was a mythicist, by the way.

I don't know what you're referring to by made up. There are certainly things that The Bible claim Jesus said, that we just don't know if he did; the general gist of the figure is true, but if you're referring to some specific events, then yes, they be ''made up''.

If a movie about Jesus is made, then obviously, they have the general gist of what he did; but they need fillers.
Reply
#48
RE: Historian explains why Jesus ''mythers'' aren't taken seriously by most Historians
That's fine, if you see the gospels as evidence, that's your decision Smile I don't. Like I said, it makes no odds to me, I'm not emotionally attached to any of this. Just calling it as I see it.

Of course stuff "could have happened" but that's not reliable history, to me.
Feel free to send me a private message.
Please visit my website here! It's got lots of information about atheism/theism and support for new atheists.

Index of useful threads and discussions
Index of my best videos
Quickstart guide to the forum
Reply
#49
RE Historian explains why Jesus ''mythers'' aren't taken seriously by most Historians

"A wise man ... proportions his belief to the evidence."
— David Hume, An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Section X, Part I.
Reply
#50
RE: Historian explains why Jesus ''mythers'' aren't taken seriously by most Historians
Reply



Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
Lightbulb POLL: As an Atheist, What Do You View as Being the Most Rational Political Outlook? Engel 129 63324 January 20, 2026 at 8:45 am
Last Post: Nay_Sayer
  Why is Jesus Circumcised and not the rest of the christians ? Megabullshit 25 16777 May 13, 2025 at 8:23 am
Last Post: awty
  British Non-Catholic Historian on Historical Longevity of the Roman Catholic Church. Nishant Xavier 36 8764 August 6, 2023 at 4:48 pm
Last Post: LinuxGal
  Atheists, if God doesnt exist, then explain why Keanu Reeves looks like Jesus Christ Frakki 9 4886 April 1, 2023 at 4:07 am
Last Post: Goosebump
  Agnosticism IS the most dishonest position R00tKiT 575 162566 March 18, 2020 at 9:24 pm
Last Post: Mr Greene
  [Not Even A Little Bit Serious] Why AREN'T You An Atheist? BrianSoddingBoru4 28 10226 December 28, 2019 at 12:48 pm
Last Post: LastPoet
  Most humans aren't too logical when it comes to world views and how to go about it. Mystic 28 9572 October 9, 2018 at 8:59 am
Last Post: Alan V
  The most horrifying journey, this is what doubting 'everything' does. Mystic 66 29941 April 3, 2018 at 4:35 pm
Last Post: The Valkyrie
  What Major Intellectual Issue Most Keeps You From Accepting The Christian Narrative? Captain Hook 324 99573 March 21, 2018 at 1:11 pm
Last Post: Kitan Etos
  Why can't Christians Verify Exactly Where Jesus Was Buried? Firefighter01 278 121997 January 19, 2017 at 8:19 am
Last Post: Little Rik



Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)