Our server costs ~$56 per month to run. Please consider donating or becoming a Patron to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
Current time: November 17, 2026, 11:57 pm

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Atheist Bible Study 1: Genesis
RE: Atheist Bible Study 1: Genesis
(December 17, 2018 at 10:31 am)unfogged Wrote:
(December 17, 2018 at 10:00 am)Grandizer Wrote: This story clearly looked to me like it was the ancient Jew's reconstruction of what they may have thought happened with a couple of ruined ancient cities that may have been observable to them. They may have also noted what looked like a pillar of salt outside of the cities, and thereby made a specific story out of that one as well. But that's just me speculating.

There are apparently many odd salt formations around the dead sea.  It isn't hard to see how they could be incorporated into a legend.

Interesting. Thanks for this tidbit.

This reminds me. There is a story that's told in my home country (Lebanon) about how a saint was once offended by a woman that he grabbed her by the boob (as she was carrying her baby) and pushed her to the wall, somehow causing her to become stone. And why this story came about was exactly to explain a weird stone formation attached to a cliff near a cave that is attributed to that saint. That formation looks like a figure carrying a child and with a boob popping out.

Also, in Lebanese Arabic (and probably Arabic, in general, not sure), we have a slang/slur word for "homosexual", which is based on the character Lot for some reason. The word is pronounced "Lootee" (as in "Lottian" or something). Never understood why exactly, but I guess it's because Lot is the main character of a story that involves men who love to have sex with other men.

(December 17, 2018 at 10:48 am)Jörmungandr Wrote: It's important to remember that this is the old testament, wherein God visited punishment for sin upon people in this life, not in a life to come.  So death in the old testament is very much a punishment, and so, if unmerited, seems like a dick move by God.  In the new testament, life before death is just a prelude to final and eternal judgement, so God killing people is less consequential.  If I'm not mistaken, it also results in a lot fewer people being killed in the new testament.

You're not mistaken. In the New Testament, divine punishment becomes more of the spiritual kind (like with many other things).
Reply
RE: Atheist Bible Study 1: Genesis
God's wrath, or divine judgement is contingent upon sin. If Sin didn't exist there would be no judgement. There is no softening of wrath from OT to NT. Sin is no less an offense to God than it is now.
"There ought to be a term that would designate those who actually follow the teachings of Jesus, since the word 'Christian' has been largely divorced from those teachings, and so polluted by fundamentalists that it has come to connote their polar opposite: intolerance, vindictive hatred, and bigotry." -- Philip Stater, Huffington Post

always working on cleaning my windows- me regarding Johari
Reply
RE: Atheist Bible Study 1: Genesis
(December 17, 2018 at 3:25 pm)tackattack Wrote: God's wrath, or divine judgement is contingent upon sin. If Sin didn't exist there would be no judgement. There is no softening of wrath from OT to NT. Sin is no less an offense to God than it is now.

Perhaps, but the means, method, and timing of that judgement, as well as Jewish understanding of it, has certainly changed.
[Image: extraordinarywoo-sig.jpg?rlkey=x1nmxbwrp...pouidnfvtl]
Reply
RE: Atheist Bible Study 1: Genesis
That's why it's called intelligent design instead of a cookie cutter God. Big Grin

Seriously though, I believe Jewish thought at the time was that the transgressions of Israel are punished in this world and the Heathens heap up woes for the next world and the day of wrath. This is clearly different than mainline Christian thought.
"There ought to be a term that would designate those who actually follow the teachings of Jesus, since the word 'Christian' has been largely divorced from those teachings, and so polluted by fundamentalists that it has come to connote their polar opposite: intolerance, vindictive hatred, and bigotry." -- Philip Stater, Huffington Post

always working on cleaning my windows- me regarding Johari
Reply
RE: Atheist Bible Study 1: Genesis
Next episode, we'll have some NSFW incest erotica happening. Angel
Reply
RE: Atheist Bible Study 1: Genesis
just don't post pictures and it'll be fine Big Grin
"There ought to be a term that would designate those who actually follow the teachings of Jesus, since the word 'Christian' has been largely divorced from those teachings, and so polluted by fundamentalists that it has come to connote their polar opposite: intolerance, vindictive hatred, and bigotry." -- Philip Stater, Huffington Post

always working on cleaning my windows- me regarding Johari
Reply
RE: Atheist Bible Study 1: Genesis
(December 17, 2018 at 3:25 pm)tackattack Wrote: God's wrath, or divine judgement is contingent upon sin. If Sin didn't exist there would be no judgement. There is no softening of wrath from OT to NT. Sin is no less an offense to God than it is now.

That's quite incorrect. In the OT there were levels of "abomination". Abomination to god, certain people/cultures, and just in general. 
A perfect being cannot "experience" offense.

(December 17, 2018 at 8:39 pm)tackattack Wrote: That's why it's called intelligent design instead of a cookie cutter God. Big Grin

Seriously though, I believe Jewish thought at the time was that the transgressions of Israel are punished in this world and the Heathens heap up woes for the next world and the day of wrath. This is clearly different than mainline Christian thought.

That's totally wrong. 
Hebrews believed all the dead went to Sheol ... both the good and the bad. 
Heaven was where Yahweh lived with the other divine beings. 
The dead did not go to heaven, nor were they "punished".


There is no agreement among archaeologists on which of the various candidates they've found of settlements along the Southwest shore of the Dead Sea, in Southern Canaan, on the Jordan River plain, that might be either one of the two settlements, used as the location for the myth in Genesis, (and it WAS a myth). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bab_edh-Dhra Bab Edh-Drah, is thought by some to be Sodom. It's like the search for Noah's Ark. It misses the point.

The archaeological evidence is not the interesting part. The myth of the "raining of fire and brimstone" was probably taken from a well known Sumerian, (or "Accadian", (Akkadian),/Assyrian-Babylonian myth), written in Cuneiform, which served as their creation myth. Part of that was the "raining" of fire and brimstone, and was written during the Akkadian Empire period, ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akkadian_Empire (--2330 BCE). There actually are large Brimstone, (Sulfur) and Lyme deposits in the area. They stink to high heaven.

Anyhow...so the myth most likely got imported/appropriated by the editors of of Genesis, when they were creating the National Story, and they used a common conventional myth from the time to make their point about hospitality, or rather IN-hospitality. The myth of Lot, in Genesis 19, about the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah, follows upon the story in Genesis 18 of Abraham, and his hospitality towards wandering strangers , (who turned out, in the myth, to be angels). So the ONLY way to understand Sodom and Gomorrah, is to keep it in context. It has NOTHING to do with sex. It all about the treatment of strangers, and stands as an example if IN-hospitality toward strangers, juxtaposed with the Abrahamic example of hospitality towards wandering strangers in the desert environment, which, of course could present a fatal danger.

There's stuff about it here, one of my favorite places : http://sabbathrock.com/tablets.aspx

Homosexuality as an "orientation" was unknown in the history of human ideas until the late Nineteenth Century.
There was no, (supposed), "lifestyle" until the Twentieth Century. The idea of "orientation" arose when Psychology began to develop as a science. All men were assumed to be straight, and only straight, all women straight, and only straight. There was also no notion of a continuum of sexual behaviors, (bisexuality), as science recognizes today.
Any "different" behavior was seen as "deviancy" from an absolute inherent norm, which the person was assumed to inherently possess, completely by virtue of birth gender.

In Ancient Israel class and status distinctions were extremely important.

The injunction in Biblical times, (Leviticus 18:22, 20:13), was against (assumed), STRAIGHT men, (and only men), (as they ALL were assumed to be straight), engaging in same-sex behaviors. (There is a mistaken use of the Sodom and Gomorrah myth in this context also, which is misguided, and I'll deal with that last).

Why ?
It had to do with class structure, and male status. A male, who held the highest position in society, and held the highest class status, was seen to be "feminized" by penetration, and designated as a social inferior, (female), by a male of lower class status, and thus his status was lowered, to that of a woman.
THAT is the reason the culture forbade it. It had NOTHING to do with sex. It was status, and only status. This concept remains very much, (subliminally and overtly), in place today. This law code, in Leviticus, (the latest law code to be written), is the ONLY place this appears in the Old Testament. The author of Leviticus was very interested in the "equality of all" before God. It was that author's agenda. He also said strangers, and others from outside Israel were all to be treated with equal rights and dignity, which was a departure, from other texts and codes. It is ironic, indeed, this equality has been turned on it's head, to treat gay people, less equality. The author of Leviticus WANTED all people treated equally, and that is why he wrote the injunction into the text, in the first place, to PREVENT inequality. The ideal society for this author was classless, and that could not happen if a male penetrates a male, and makes him thereby, a lower class. It's about class, not sex.

This cultural origin was true in the Old Testament culture, as well as the New. That is the reason it ended up in the Bible, and the ONLY reason it was there.

The law in the Old Testament : "You shall not lay a male as with the laying of a woman, it is an offensive thing". (note: the correct translation is NOT, "it is an abomination"). (The word "toi-va" is used, and in archaic Hebrew, EVERYWHERE else is translated, "an offensive thing").

Why is this important ? Because there are levels of "offensive things", and levels of meanings of "offensive things".

There were a number of levels of offensive things in the Old Testament.

#1. was something which was offensive to God, and this was the worst.
#2. was something which was offensive to other peoples and cultures, (for example the same word is used with reference to some foods being "offensive" to other cultures, (as hagas might be to Americans), or for example the Egyptians didn't eat, with non-Egyptians, as that was "offensive", or in today's language, "bad manners".
#3. was something which was just generally "offensive", with no further relational attribution.

So it can be "offensive" to some people, but not everyone, and is relative to the situation, or to god, or just in general.

The injunction against male same sex behavior is the third kind of offensive. It's not related to either God or anything, or anyone else.
(There are other verses around it that are stated to be offensive to God, but not this one).
So in this text, it is offensive to the authors of the text, and that specific culture, (only).

Same-sex behaviors (upper class man penetrated by same class or lower class men), was forbidden, for class reasons.
Equal class men, doing non-penetrating activity, or women together was not forbidden.
( Woman with woman, in general, was not addressed, and the class issue was not important.)

So what does this tell us ?
It tells us the laws were written into the Bible by HUMANS, for human culturally relative, and internally referenced reasons.
The laws in the Bible REFLECTED their OWN culture, of the times, and did not "inform" the culture.
The direction of information flow is crucial. Every Biblical scholar knows this. The Bible was informed by the culture, NOT the other way around.
There are no "ultimate" claims possible from culturally relative, historically rooted, human local customs.

The other main text used to justify the fundamentalist nonsense about homosexuality, is the Sodom and Gomorrah myth in Genesis.

Hospitality of Abraham : In Genesis 18, there is a myth about the hospitality of Abraham, (he welcomes two strangers, who turn out to be angels), as that was an important cultural value, in a society where a wandering desert dweller could get lost, and die.

The myth is followed closely by it's counter example of in-hospitality in the Lot myth, (Sodom and Gomorrah). It is not about sex. It's a counter example to the hospitality story, of in-hospitality. The context is important.

The great irony is that some religious fundies use the Bible to keep gay people away from their "table", and feasts, using the very texts that the Bible intended to teach hospitality, to do the opposite.

ref : Drs. Shawna Dolansky, and Richard Elliott Friedman, "The Bible Now", and "Who Wrote the Bible"

It would really help if religionists got their facts straight, and learned about their fucking Bible.

(December 17, 2018 at 3:25 pm)tackattack Wrote: God's wrath, or divine judgement is contingent upon sin. If Sin didn't exist there would be no judgement. There is no softening of wrath from OT to NT. Sin is no less an offense to God than it is now.

Oh really ? What sin have infants that die of cancer committed ?
Every religion is true one way or another. It is true when understood metaphorically. But when it gets stuck in its own metaphors, interpreting them as facts, then you are in trouble. - Joseph Campbell  Popcorn

Militant Atheist Commie Evolutionist 
Reply
RE: Atheist Bible Study 1: Genesis
"There ought to be a term that would designate those who actually follow the teachings of Jesus, since the word 'Christian' has been largely divorced from those teachings, and so polluted by fundamentalists that it has come to connote their polar opposite: intolerance, vindictive hatred, and bigotry." -- Philip Stater, Huffington Post

always working on cleaning my windows- me regarding Johari
Reply
RE: Atheist Bible Study 1: Genesis
Every religion is true one way or another. It is true when understood metaphorically. But when it gets stuck in its own metaphors, interpreting them as facts, then you are in trouble. - Joseph Campbell  Popcorn

Militant Atheist Commie Evolutionist 
Reply
RE: Atheist Bible Study 1: Genesis
BTW, you didn't answer :
Quote:Oh really ? What sin have infants that die of cancer committed ?
Every religion is true one way or another. It is true when understood metaphorically. But when it gets stuck in its own metaphors, interpreting them as facts, then you are in trouble. - Joseph Campbell  Popcorn

Militant Atheist Commie Evolutionist 
Reply



Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Genesis 1:26 is not implying God is triune GrandizerII 5 3095 August 12, 2025 at 9:40 pm
Last Post: GrandizerII
  Is this a contradiction or am I reading it wrong? Genesis 5:28 Ferrocyanide 110 45238 April 10, 2023 at 3:32 pm
Last Post: Ferrocyanide
  There are no answers in Genesis LinuxGal 248 73204 March 24, 2023 at 7:34 pm
Last Post: Ferrocyanide
  Without citing the bible, what marks the bible as the one book with God's message? Whateverist 143 76624 March 31, 2022 at 7:05 am
Last Post: Gwaithmir
  Evangelicals, Trump and a Quick Bible Study DeistPaladin 52 16524 November 9, 2020 at 3:20 pm
Last Post: downbeatplumb
  Bibe Study 2: Questionable Morality Rhondazvous 30 9381 May 27, 2019 at 12:23 pm
Last Post: Vicki Q
  Bible Study: The God who Lies and Deceives Rhondazvous 50 17143 May 24, 2019 at 5:52 pm
Last Post: Aegon
  Genesis interpretations - how many are there? Fake Messiah 129 46845 January 22, 2019 at 7:33 pm
Last Post: donlor
  Free interpretation of the Genesis 3:5 KJV theBorg 19 7734 November 13, 2016 at 2:03 am
Last Post: RiddledWithFear
  Genesis - The Prequel! Time Traveler 12 6329 May 17, 2016 at 1:16 am
Last Post: Love333



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)